Showing posts with label arizona housing crash. Show all posts
Showing posts with label arizona housing crash. Show all posts

May 21, 2008

Jay Butler, Director of "Real-Estate Studies" at Arizona State University, flunks out


Other blogs like housingdoom have always been a bit dubious of Butler and his reports - almost as much as we've taken on the hilariously corrupt Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, and their paid REIC shill Nicholas Retsinas.

But I haven't been too hard though on Butler, because he hasn't been stupid enough to attack HP'ers, unlike "Chicken Littles" Retsinas. And he's had some
good quotes now that it's too late.

That said, the biggest housing bubble in America, and now one of the biggest real estate crashes, happened right under Butler's nose in Phoenix Arizona. And when he could have been and should have been shouting at the top of his lungs in 2004, 2005 and 2006 that wild illegal fraud and rampant speculation had gripped the Arizona real estate market and doing something about it, he did nothing, while putting out misleading soothing reports, and calling bottom every chance he could.

Well, today the chickens really came home to roost, and the REIC-ad-supported Arizona Republic (don't worry, it's a real reporter on the beat, not rolodex-of-realtors-Reagor) actually did their job for a change and exposed Butler's Arizona housing reports as a total farce.

Cheers to the Republic for exposing this mess. And I fully expect Butler to admit to his glaring error, and if he has any honor, to resign immediately. ASU isn't a legit school anyway, but when the people of Arizona needed 'experts' they could trust, they got Butler. And Swann. And Reagor. And now one hell of a housing mess on their hands.

Valley home-sales reports are at odds - Trustee-sales figures skew real-estate picture

One sign of the Valley's troubled housing market is the growing incidence of lenders assuming ownership of homes.

Ironically, the increasing number of those transactions has led to a false perception that the real-estate market may be showing signs of recovery.

The confusion stems from a report on April home sales by Jay Butler, director of real-estate studies at Arizona State University's Morrison School of Management and Agribusiness.

Butler compiles a report each month on home-resale transactions in Maricopa County.

The report said home resales were up 15 percent compared with the same month in 2007, the first year-over-year increase since July 2005.

That conflicts with a report released Monday by the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service indicating a 12 percent decrease in home sales in the same period.

The reason is Butler's report does not differentiate between "trustee sales," in which banks take over properties from borrowers in default, and routine home resales.

More than one-third of the sales reported by Butler for April, or 2,025 of the 5,585 total, were trustee sales.

When real-estate consultant Scott Smith saw Butler's latest report, Smith said he knew something was wrong with the numbers. Smith, who owns a real-estate services firm and tracks area home sales "on a daily basis," said Butler's April sales figures were simply too high.

"After checking the data several times . . . there is no doubt that Mr. Butler made a big mistake," Smith said.

April 06, 2008

NYT Arizona crash expose: "stuck in the middle of the desert, saddled with spacious new houses that had become not a promise of a future but a burden"


If I were to end the blog today with a story that would wrap things up, this one in the Times today would be it.

Before leaving for Europe, I took a trip down to Maricopa Arizona, 40 miles south of Phoenix, in the Fall of 2005, and couldn't believe what I saw. In the middle of nowhere, and I mean THE MIDDLE OF FREAKING NOWHERE, there were homes going up like weeds in the desert, and there were crowds lined up to get in the doors.

I went into four of the developments - a Pulte, a Centex, a KB Home and I forget the fourth, and the homes were monuments to 2x4 bad construction, painfully terrible architecture and unlivable layouts. And of course, they were located in a place that homes should never have been allowed to be built, and a place that nobody in their right minds would ever buy a home, at any price.

And yet look at all the cars and pickup trucks (damn - lots of illegals here!) filled with bright eyed buyers. Look at all the selling agents all too eager to tell you how appreciation was 'in the bag', how it was a 'great time to buy' because prices were going up next week, and how easy it was to get a mortgage at a great low introductory rate from their lender.

And I decided right there and then to start a blog to warn people about what was happening, and what was to come. I had seen enough.

This one has it all HP'ers. It's long, so grab a cup of coffee, read the whole thing, and then comment. It's too bad the screwed homedebtor in the article didn't read HP or all the other sources that would have and should have scared him away from such a stupid decision. This article sticks out for me - from July 2006, before the sheeple in today's story made his mistake:

"Scott Helsel never figured on being a real estate agent.But Prudential Arizona Properties has been lucrative for him. Especially with home builders in the Maricopa area so desperate they're offering real estate agents double or triple commission rates to bring them clients, knocking prices down by tens of thousands of dollars or tossing in free pools and other upgrades."

So today's expose has the ignorant and now-screwed homedebtor. It's got the pre-foreclosure home renting out at a fraction of the cost of owning, desperate realtors on commission, and sheeple buying badly-located homes they couldn't afford and shouldn't have bought in an area too boring for words. It has the destroyed dreams, the closed businesses, the screwed town, the sea of foreclosures, and the lifetimes of savings lost. And it has the epic real estate collapse in Ponzi-Scheme-Central Phoenix Arizona.

Thank you realtors. Thank you mortgage brokers. Thank you builders. Thank you appraisers. You f*cked people like Daryl Fox for a commission, even as he f*cked himself. And now we all pay the price.

And a message to Congress: DO NOT F*CK WITH THIS MARKET. PRICES NEED TO FALL TO THEIR MARKET PRICE. HOMEDEBTORS THAT SCREWED UP HAVE TO GIVE THE HOMES BACK TO THE BANKS AND START OVER. THE BANKS THEN HAVE TO FAIL. AND THEN WE CAN ALL MOVE ON.

Here's the sad and all-too-familiar story. Post good clips and bites in the comments thread.

Thanks Frank for the link.

March 16, 2008

Do the states and cities of America know how screwed they are now that their sales tax and property tax party is over?


Schools will close

Firehouses will close

Roads won't be repaired

Workers will be laid off

Crime will soar

Cities will go into decline

Tax rates will go up

This will not be pretty. Especially in LA, Phoenix, Vegas, Miami, Tampa and San Diego.

You'll also start hearing soon about cities defaulting on their debt, and going bankrupt. We're just days away from that.

You would have thought after the dot-com bubble that local and state governments would have learned their lesson and prepared for a rainy day. But this bubble bust will hurt them so much worse as they lose their sales tax revenue (so long HELOC buying binges) as well as their real estate taxes which will plummet along with the price of the taxed properties.


We're still just getting started. We know the cause, now it's time to see the effects.

December 10, 2007

A silly question.. How can a home in Arizona appraised a few weeks ago for $2.2 million be listed for sale today at $1.4 million?

Anyone else think we have a major problem with the entire corrupted housing appraisal system in the US? Or maybe Phoenix real estate is simply crashing fast and furious now...

Hmmm...

December 06, 2007

PIMCO nukes US housing - predicts 30% fall from peak and says Bush/Paulson plan "reeks of moral hazard"


Nice to see HP isn't the only one who think George Bush and Henry Paulson are corrupt incompetent tone-deaf idiots, and that the US housing market is in the early stages of a historic Japan-like crash.

I swear, it amazes me that we ended up with such incompetent leadership in DC. Bush and Paulson are the new Dukes of (Moral) Hazard.


But then again, the American people voted for these losers, and the leadership of a democracy reflects the people. 'Nuff said.

BOTTOM LINE - THIS BUSH/PAULSON HOUSING GAMBLER MORAL HAZARD BAILOUT MUST BE STOPPED AT ALL COSTS. AMERICAN BUSINESS PRACTICES WILL HAVE NO CREDIBILITY WORLDWIDE IF THIS GOES THROUGH, AND WE'LL BE NO WORSE THAN VENEZUELA OR ZIMBABWE

US home prices may bottom out in 2010, Pimco says

A senior manager at the world's biggest bond fund criticized a federal mortgage rescue plan as short-sighted and said U.S. home prices may not hit bottom until 2010.

U.S. home prices may fall as much as 30 percent from the market's peak and likely won't trough until 2009 to 2010, according to Mark Kiesel, a portfolio manager at Pacific Investment Management Co.

"The question is, do we do it over a period of two to three years, or do we do it in 10?" Kiesel said in an interview. "Japan chose 10, and that didn't work so well."

Kiesel, a longtime bear on the U.S. housing market, also questioned merits of a plan that President George W. Bush is expected to unveil on Thursday to help struggling American homeowners avoid foreclosure.

"This reeks of moral hazard," Kiesel said. "This is pure politics as we enter an election year, and it's not going to help the problem. It's going to prolong the bubble."

Kiesel said government interference in the free market may do more harm than good.

"A government bailout which alters contractual interest payments to bondholders will fuel moral hazard problems and raise mortgage rates for future borrowers and home buyers," he said. "This is not a path we want to head down in which government intervention bails out homeowners who failed to act responsibly."

December 03, 2007

FLASH: Housing crash over! Phoenix has year-round golf and pro athletes!


Since we recently published the Time magazine "goo goo for housing" cover, and the Century 21 "Suzanne" commercial, I thought I'd hit for the trifecta and remind HP'ers of the stupidest realtor we've ever seen, and his now-hilarious 21 reasons why the Phoenix housing market wouldn't crash.

The chart above is for all of Phoenix (Maricopa County) c/o zillow.com. F*ck that's ugly, and it's gonna get worse. I guess the good news is the golf might get cheaper...


Damn, I pity that clueless realtor's clients. If he has any. They likely lost everything by now, all because they listened to a realtor who had no idea what he was talking about, except for his commission.

Here's reasons #20 and #21 - you'll have to google to find the rest. And please feel free to add to the "21 Reasons the Phoenix Housing Crash Will Be Historic" list.

20. A significant number of active and retired professional athletes maintain homes here, in no small part because the Phoenix/Scottsdale area has… 21. Year-around golf.

November 03, 2007

HousingPANIC Stupid Question of the Day


Anyone stopping by new home developments and open houses just for fun?

You know, do the P/E math with the listing agent, chit-chat about the housing crash, ask about the massive incentives and fire-sale pricing, and talk about maybe making an offer for 50% off?

October 21, 2007

"Brutal" and "Perfect Storm". Arizona's fake housing-based economy spinning out of control as real estate market crashes



Everyone in Arizona glad they listened to idiot realtors on commission these past couple of years?

But what about all the jobs! What about all the immigrants! What about the fact they're not making any more land! What about the 365-days of golf!

Sorry. Something called gravity has now taken hold. Buckle up. Arizona housing prices are going to crash right back to pre-speculation inflation-adjusted 2001 levels, and might not even stop there. And the general Arizona housing-based economy will go into depression levels soon. When you build your fake economy on one fake industry full of fakes and fake promises, and then that fake industry blows up, things get real ugly, and that ain't fake.

Thanks to Doom for the great (and ugly!) charts. 17 month supply of homes in Phoenix. Ugly. I guess there aren't 21 reasons to buy homes today in housing-crash central Arizona.

Housing worries generally optimistic Valley experts

"Brutal" and "perfect storm" are some of the descriptions local economists now use to describe economic conditions in Maricopa County.

"I think this will be a brutal year," said Dennis Hoffman,an Arizona State University economist who helps guide sales tax forecasts for the state.

In an interview, he said "I think it has a lot to do with the fact that our local sales tax revenues are tied to this new house-new car phenonomen, decorating the house, doing maintenance and repairs and adding new carpeting, furniture and fixtures."

Economist Elliott Pollack reiterated that the housing market is a serious worry because there are so many houses on the market and lending standards have become tougher. Also the housing slump could slow migration into the state because homeowners in other states can't sell their houses to move here, he said.
"We especially have a perfect storm in the housing market," he said.

Local reality show exposes housing woes of the rich


The Landrys say they think viewers will warm up to their subjects for courageously airing their financial woes in public, something many in their social stratum consider the greatest taboo.

“There are actually a lot of people at the Mahans' economic level who are facing those same foreclosure fears now, but they cover it up,” said John Landry, a retired architect who now works as a real-estate agent, “so nobody ever knows.”

Many sellers slash prices to sell homes


A Chandler man slashed his price by $60,000 to sell his home so he and his wife could move to Ahwatukee.

An east Mesa women accepted about $25,000 less than her original asking price even after installing carpet, remodeling a bathroom, upgrading the swimming pool and adding a $7,000 hot tub and a $2,000 shed.

Their tactics weren't extraordinary in the ongoing housing downturn, where prices are falling by double-digit percentages in some cases.

"Realtors need to have a discussion with sellers because appraisal value and market value are two different things now," she said.

October 19, 2007

I just had to post... Department of Homeland Security running "what if a dirty bomb went off in Scottsdale" drills

Frank, this one's for you...


If a dirty bomb did go off in Tempe/Phoenix/Mesa/Scottsdale, would that be a plus or a minus for local home prices? Would desperate homedebtors be able to get out of their debt-bomb mortgages easier for something like this, versus the arson that they're currently considering?

Hmmm... From dirtyscottsdale to dirtybombscottsdale. Don't get any ideas Arizonans!

On Tuesday, at 9 a.m., a radioactive "dirty bomb" exploded at the intersection of Loops 101 and 202, where Tempe and Mesa meet, a half-mile south of the Scottsdale city limits, causing hundreds of casualties and threatening the lives of perhaps tens of thousands more and instantly crippling a major transportation artery.

We are still searching for new victims. . . . Our communications capacity, disaster-relief and evacuation planning will all be under severe strain before the crisis passes.

Actually, Tuesday's disaster was a drill. No more real than an episode of 24. No bomb was actually detonated. No citizens were hurt.

The catastrophe and its aftermath are still being played out this week in several command centers, one in a Chandler hotel.

It's part of TOPOFF 4, a federal emergency exercise, conducted simultaneously in Arizona, Guam and Oregon.

Coordinated by the Department of Homeland Security, it is the fourth and largest of its kind, mandated by Congress before 9/11.

October 11, 2007

Random look at housing crash through zillow zip code graphs. Here's a slice of Phoenix (85323). Any questions?


I took a quick spin on zillow.com (you know you love it) today to check out the freefall in home prices in my old 'hood, Phoenix Arizona.

It wasn't pretty.

I also looked at real estate foreclosures and noticed a bunch of units in my old development heading to auction. Gee, what a shocker. When "ownership" prices skyrocketed to three times the cost of renting, and flippers were buying at any price, you just knew how this one would end.

And end it has. And now, it's a long, long, long way back down.

And the clueless homedebtors and cheerleader realtors in Phoenix still have no idea what hit 'em.


October 10, 2007

Hi. I'm Angelo Mozilo of Countrywide. I duped homedebtors into signing up for toxic loans and then I dumped hundreds of millions in CFC stock.



Any questions? Good. Oh, I also had my company buy back stock with shareholder money to prop up the price as I dumped it. Any questions? Good. Oh, I also laid off thousands of Countrywide employees as I was enriching myself. Any questions? Good.

(note - just like Angelo I'm still short CFC)

Some executives might be tempted to establish plans to sell stock when they anticipate the stock price might fall in a coming quarter, perhaps because a big customer has warned it intends to renegotiate a contract. And erratic trading also looks suspicious, even though that could occur because the stock misses a target price for months at a time.

But the suspicions are especially keen, the panelists said, when executives modify, suspend or terminate their plans. For example, a pension is suing Countrywide Financial after CEO Angelo Mozilo sold more than $50 million of stock through a 10b5-1 plan he had modified about the time when regulators were scrutinizing subprime loans.

"I think it's dangerous to terminate or modify a plan," said Alan Dye, a partner with Hogan & Hartson in Washington D.C.

"It's better to just go ahead and live with the plan."

October 03, 2007

HousingPANIC Stupid Question of the Day


One day on this blog, I'll say "OK folks, that's it. The fundamentals are back in line, you can buy a house now and rent it out for positive cash flow, and the Late Great Housing Bubble has been deflated. Go out and buy homes again (but don't use a realtor!)"

So what calendar date do you think that will that be (be specific)?

NEW YORK (Reuters) - U.S. housing prices may not start recovering until 2010 or 2011, according to a Barron's report that quotes bond fund manager Jeffrey Gundlach.

The report in the October 1 edition cites a Gundlach forecast that U.S. home prices may drop an average of 12 percent to 15 percent annually and not reach a trough until late 2008.

According to the report, Gundlach sees particularly sharp declines in bubble markets of California, Florida, Nevada and Arizona and areas in Michigan, Ohio and Indiana, with price drops of 30 percent to 40 percent in those areas.

September 21, 2007

Funny youtube video on the mortgage meltdown and housing crash - "There's a Fine Fine Line Between a Gain and a Painful Decline"

Hat-tip to Doom for the find. Hilarious (and pretty catchy). You'll be singing this one in the shower. Very Avenue Q for those of you in the know...

September 06, 2007

FLASH: Foreclosures soaring, and in mortgage meltdown cities failed flippers are just turning in the keys

Goodbye Florida.

Goodbye Arizona.

Goodbye California.

Goodbye Nevada.

And hello 50% falls in home values. No matter what lying realtors on commission try to tell you.

Subprime Mortgage Woes Push New Foreclosures to a Record High

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The number of homeowners receiving foreclosure notices hit a record high in the spring, driven up by problems with subprime mortgages.

Analysts said the problems in the formerly red-hot housing markets of California, Florida, Nevada and Arizona reflected in part speculators walking away from mortgages they can no longer afford.

During a five-year housing boom, the prices in these areas surged, creating what many analysts have described as a speculative bubble as investors bid up the price of homes hoping to quickly resell them for a profit.

Now with home sales falling, the inventory of unsold homes rising and prices stagnant, some speculators are choosing to default on their mortgages.

September 01, 2007

Phoenix Housing Crash Parody Youtube Video - "Free Falling - Now I'm Defaulting"



Gotta love stuff like this. "Free falling - Now I'm defaulting... gonna have negative equity for awhile" - love it. Thanks again doom for the link.

Anyone still believe Phoenix realtors on commission?


August 19, 2007

How bad is the housing crash getting in Phoenix? Here's a home $220,000 below appraisal - yours to buy or maybe even commit mortgage fraud!

Hell, you find a home in housing-crash-central-Phoenix listed at $220,000 below appraisal, just go get yourself a loan for the appraised amount with no down and no doc (IndyMac might be able to help you there if you hurry), move in, then do the American thing and NEVER MAKE A PAYMENT.


Meanwhile, take the $220,000 and transfer it to your Swiss bank account, and just walk away.

Sweet!

Or if you really want to "own" it, go ahead and buy. And see how quick you can lose another $220,000. Or try to rent it out, and ask yourself why renters would only pay 30% of what your cost to "own" would be.

Welcome to HousingPANIC.

$900000 $220k below RECENT appraisal, builder desperate

Priced to move, this WEEK! Not in MLS. No agents please. This is a Pre-foreclosure.

This home is really just one of about 11 other high-end foreclosure or pre-foreclosure homes in the Desert Hills, Cave Creek, or Carefree areas. What is it you are exactly looking for? We can send you a detailed list of all “instant equity on the buy - value purchases” in the area.

August 06, 2007

CNBC's Diana Olick spells it out. "American homeowners got greedy, bottom line"

Here's Diana on why the Fed shouldn't lower interest rates to bail out greedy flippers and the corrupt REIC. Also check out this full thread as it deals with Cramer's meltdown from Friday.

Since Diana is an HP reader, if you want her to dig deeper on something, or have any kudos or criticisms, use this tread...

"American homeowners got greedy, bottom line. They saw these low rates, they saw these "exotic" mortgage products, and they bought themselves homes they should never have owned in the first place. Now they're in trouble, and many of them should be."

"Yes, there was plenty of predatory lending and plenty of illegal and immoral practices going on in brokers' offices in every state of the U.S., but the bulk of the boom was driven by straight-up brokers with straight-up documents that just happened to offer very cheap money for a short time. People didn't read their papers, didn't take the time to understand their investments and now they're getting burned."

Get used to these statements from failed mortgage lenders and homebuilders

American Home has ceased taking mortgage applications and has notified all of its production employees that they will be separated effective tomorrow, August 3, 2007. Accordingly, the Company employee base will be reduced from over 7,000 to approximately 750. The Company currently is maintaining its thrift and servicing businesses.

Michael Strauss, American Home's Chief Executive Officer, stated,

"It is with great sadness that American Home has had to take this action which involves so many dedicated employees. The employees affected should understand that this is not a reflection on their efforts or their productivity.

Unfortunately, the market conditions in both the secondary mortgage market as well as the national real estate market have deteriorated to the point that we have no realistic alternative."

July 28, 2007

HousingPANIC Stupid Question of the Day


Question for HP'ers: Did HP and the other bubble blogs help save you from doing something really really stupid?

Here's a great and inspiring letter over at the always excellent
housingdoom. Some people ask why I do HP. This is why. I imagine all the other bubble bloggers would say the same. To help our fellow man, and to get the word out about the corrupt REIC (realtors, mortgage brokers, lenders, appraisers, builders) who screwed America.

July 22, 2007

This garage, errr, house, is an actual new home for sale in Phoenix - home of the housing crash and butt-ugly overpriced new houses nobody wants


At what point did Americans, and especially Phoenicians, decide that ugly houses, soulless cookie-cutter neighborhoods and unplanned urban sprawl were good things?

Bleeeccckkkk.

How sad.

How long until they tear down these things down?

You wonder why these things aren't selling anymore - at any price.