January 11, 2006

New: BUBBLE TALK ongoing chat area - talk about any housing topic you'd like here

Hey, it's your blog too - talk about anything you want here, as long it's about our little friend, the housing bubble, in some way


Anonymous said...

Where can I find the most overpriced housing in DC?
The evidence has been accumulating since August - the housing bubble in DC has started to burst. Sales are falling, inventory is increasing and the ratio of house prices to median incomes are at a record high. The fed has been hiking interest rates since late 2004; and at least two more 0.25 percent increases are likely in the first 6 months of next year. Many DC borrowers are particularly vulnerable to increasing interest rates. Last year, 38 percent of house purchases were financed with high risk interest only mortgages. Next year will be ugly, ugly, ugly for the flippers and speculators.

After four years of realtor hype, prices in some areas were pushed higher than others. It is well understood that Condos now look like a disastrous investment. But what about communities? Parts of NE and SW have been overpriced with claims of gentrification, but were the worst excesses in the previously low income parts of DC? Which part of metro DC is going to take the hardest hit; Silver Spring? Friendship Heights? G-town?

foxwoodlief said...

How can we compare apples and oranges when talking about price and bubbles? We can't totally use median price of home prices for the past 30 years because homes have gotten larger and have more ammenities than in the past. I think price per sq ft is a good measure for comparisons but how do you show the adjustment for inflation as well as the difference in the cost and types of materials used? A 1950s house may have been of brick and wood floors and today have many dated features or materials not used. My parent's home in Los Gatos, California was a little over 1100 sq ft when they bought it in 1963 for $17,000. It was a basic starter home, stuco over chicken-wire, oak floors, fireplace, average yard, two car garage, 1 1/2 baths, nothing by today's standards. So they paid about $16 a sq foot. Today that would be around $97 a sq ft and in some markets like Austin that buys a lot more in ammenities like real stone and brick instead of stucco, granite counters, tile floors etc. So how can we escape the hype of a bubble with the reality of lcoation, quality, and cost per sq foot?

foxwoodlief said...

Also some of those charts posted that show the median price of a home going up if you added the average size of a home during that time period and then found the average cost per sq ft and adjusted it for inflation, most of the numbers always come out to around $94 a sq ft. Can we find some rational point of cost in additon to historical costs of 2,3, 4 times income in historically high cost areas and desirable locations? Also look at how cost of housing have come down compared to homes in say the 1800s and the number of home owners having gone up? Even if you bought a home at a fire sale the eventual cost of remodling and updating an older home to code and modern ammenties drive one to some sort of baseline price per sq footage, no? I know I bought a home in 1989 in a run down Tampa neighborhood for $23,000 and it was 3500 sq ft built in 1905 and I had invested a lot of blood, sweat and tears for two years plus a lot of money renovating it myself (so saving the cost of contractors) and by the end the real cost of the home had risen to $90,000 and could have gone much higher if I had to pay for plumbers, carpenters, painters, and maybe even put in a gourmet and baths. Any guidance on price relevancy?

Anonymous said...

On Christmas Day I went to visit a relative in the BUBBLE zone of Twin Lakes/Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. They say that once you pass the Wisconsin border you have passed the Cheddar Curtain.... Anyway the tear down mania run by speculators is converting many old summer homes into 6000 sq ft plus three story vertical homes. The real estate taxes in this area are among the highest in the USA. How would you like to pay 200,000 Dollars a year in Real Estate Taxes!!!!! You can on Lake Geneva! The real estate taxes on lake property have doubled in the last three years! The city government of Lake Geneva has the highest per capita tax collections in the state of Wisconsin and it is NOT ENOUGH! The schools are crying that they need more.......

Anyway, the bubble in this area appears to have burst. The properties according to sources are just laying on the market. I was told the story of one home owner who wanted 1.1 Million for his small lake front home on Lame Elizabeth who got an offer of 800,000 and turned it down..... FOOL! This home has been on the market since Spring.
Owner should have taken the 800 grand and RUN!

I went by an other new subdivision on the South Shore of Lake Geneva, the former property of the Northwestern Military Acadamy. What was interesting to see was a tent set up sheltering a map of the new mega buck subdivision. There were several new spec homes up priming the big buck pump! It looks like the RE agents had spent the day their out in the COLD under the tent desperately waiting for the drive bys! I think they will wait a long time!

keith said...

foxwood - I'll see if I can find an analysis of housing prices per sq. ft. adjusted for inflation on an annual basis since say 1930. That's what we need.

Anon in WI - here's something that NOBODY is talking about. During the .com days, all that extra cap-gains tax flowed into US and State coffers, and it was gravy days.

Same thing is happening today at the State level - as housing gains flow in in the form of property and sales tax receipts. That's why states that were in desperate shape just 2 to 3 years ago are now flush with windfall cash.

But... what happens when the bubble pops? Do state appraisers take the appraisals they use for tax basis down? I think not. Do they have a plan for their receipts to drop (sales tax first then housing tax)? I think not.

Bottom line, homeowners are gonna see huge tax increases at the same time the interest only and ARM crowd is going to see huge payment increases. Double whammy.

And the states will be in a world of hurt in 2006 when retail sales drop off as wealth effect subsides.

Here we go again.

Anonymous said...

I used to live in stuart florida until dec 1st. I took my money and ran to a cheaper market. Anyway i was talking to one of my best friends there on sunday. She works for a very big RE broker there. She bought 2 condo's there one on the beach and one preconstruction unit, and she has another she lives in. She told me that she wants to keep the ocean front condo if she can. She has a 7 year arm right now and she pays about 2500 dollars, which is to much to pay for her. She is getting refinaced with a 1% interest loan that is another 5-7 year arm type loan. Her new payment will be about 1500, much more affordable to her. I think she is refinacing for about 450k? My question is how exactly does this loan work? Does anyone know? She bought her second spec condo for 190k, they are just getting finished now. 299k was here first listing price. i'll keep updating to see how that market is going for her. mchinup

Anonymous said...

11 Condo's coming on the market, 575-1200 Sq. Ft..these condos are in 4 buildings.
Photo 1
Photo 2

The owner was unable to unload his investment properties ($369k & $790k) so he's taken them off the market and is repositioning them as "affordable housing" units.

These condos appear to be in 100-year old buildings with 50 years of deferred maintenance and no off-street parking.

Are you aware of any other community that has seen the downside of condo conversions? Are there any communities which have placed restrictions on condo conversions such as requiring a capital reserve account be fully seeded before handing the project over to an association?

I am supportive of attempts to bring affordable housing units on the market but my sense is that these new owners will be paying more in mortgage payments than the units had previously rented out for and will then be saddled with onerous condo dues as they take on maintenance and repairs of these buildings.

Anonymous said...

[But... what happens when the bubble pops? Do state appraisers take the appraisals they use for tax basis down? I think not. Do they have a plan for their receipts to drop (sales tax first then housing tax)? I think not] Keith In mass when prices go up the mill rate comes down to keep the tax rate about the same. In Florida they don't do that. People are going to get huge tax bill and the county's are using every penny. The new people moving in there are going to be screwed. I just sold my house there in dec, my taxes were 3000 because i was homesteaded. The new owner will be slammed with a 10k dollar tax bill. Florida will be in trouble in the long run IMO. She was already complaining that her insurance bill was almost 3 times what mine was. Quite a few insurance companies are not writing in florida now. The state better start thinking of a new tax plan there, or there will be hell to pay soon. Imagine 13k for taxes and insurance on a 3 bedroon 2 bath house? Florida is headed for some trouble down the line, JMO mrchinup

Anonymous said...

There is concern in the Midwest that many of the new jobs created since the dot-com recession were related to real estate bubble/boom ie new builders, remodelers, re agents/brokers, mortgage brokers, Home Depot clercks, furniture store workers, etc.

While all this was going on, the manufacturing base of the region continued to disappear at a rapid rate.

Thus as the boom/bubble deflates, the new jobs will disaappear along with it AND there will no jobs to fall back on.

According to a recent report the medium income per person in the MIDWEST RUST BELT is already back to where it was in 1989! Michigan was at the bottom, Illinois was next, Ohio was right there too.

Question: will there be enough jobs at Walmart, Target, TJ Maxx, K-Mart, to absorb all these people and will they with their lower pay be able to afford their MORTGAGES!?

http://www.jibjab.com Click on BIG BOX STORE The year in review is also good......

Anonymous said...

Why is it that whenever I see a local newspaper print an article about the bubble busting 2006 I see the same basic story?

-"The dramatic increase in real estate prices was due primarily to low interest rates and now that interest rates have gone up, sales have slowed down"

(What about the fact that speculators have driven up prices too damn high causing demand to diminish?)

-"Economist for XYZ reality association/bank says we expect modest declines in 2006 and a nice soft landing"

(The economists for the real estate and mortgage industries wouldn't have a vested interest in trying to convince everyone there will be a soft landing, would they?)

-In markets that didn't see the double-digit price increases you see this line,” since we didn't see the dramatic run up in prices here in ABC City, we don't expect large price decreases. But watch out in those overheated markets."

-In markets that did see the big increases you see lines like,” inventory is up, but sales are still strong and we expect this to continue into 2006. We see this all the time in real estate, just when you think things will go down, it always goes up, up, up."

I just wanted to point out that faced with the facts people have begun to acknowledge that there is a housing bubble, but are still in denial as to the extent of the ramifications. The "it won't affect our community" crowd just doesn’t understand that in the age of globalization, this already is a worldwide phenomenon.

keith said...

From my Daily Reckoning email (www.dailyreckoning.com) a good observation today that I'll post here for reaction:


Incomes per hour are not going up - they're going down. And the average
man...as we recall the data...has no more real spending power per hour
worked than he did 30 years ago. Is he richer? Hmmm...his house went up
price. His wife went to work. Interest rates went down...finance
invented new ways to lend him money...so he can spend more. But what is
that brings him the extra spending power? Is he really benefiting from
this new, post-industrial economy? Does he get a share of the profits
selling iPods? Does he get royalties on Disney movies? Not likely.

And why should he? Inherently, an hour of his time is no more valuable
than that of a Chinese person. Why should he earn more? Why should he
richer? Whence cometh the extra loot? In the past, the answer was
The factories - representing huge, fixed capital outlays - were in his
backyard, not in China's. Now what's in his backyard that makes his
so much pricier? The new post-industrial 'platform' companies are freer
move about. He cannot get a grip on them. He cannot force higher wages
of them. Nor is he in a better position to own their shares than an
investor from Paris or Manila.

He had a huge advantage when America was an industrial country - the
factory could not escape. He and other workers could unionize and
the capitalists. No more. Where is his advantage? Is he better educated
than the Chinese? Has he more oil in his backyard? Has he more skills?
Even if the platform, creative, genius companies were more profitable
the factories...why would they give this fellow a piece of the profits?

Not that we're getting misty eyed over the fate of the poor lumpen.
had it good for a very long time. If it ain't so good in the future,
that is just the way things work. But he really has no way to increase
purchasing power -- faced with billions of competitors in the East --
will the U.S. domestic market grow? How will he pay back all the money
borrowed? How will he keep up with payments...with spending...with
little setbacks...when the credit flows less like Kool-Aid and more

We don't know. But we wouldn't want to hold his mortgage. And we
that the marvelous performance of the U.S. economy over the last few
is a trap and a swindle. It was caused not by a dynamic new economic
model, but an old-fashioned credit binge.

41cadillac said...

What is the take on this!

Home prices zoom up in NovemberBy MATTHEW HAGGMANmhaggman@MiamiHerald.comHome prices jumped sharply in November, appearing to counter worries the South Florida housing market is slowing down.
The median price of an existing single-family home jumped to $391,100 in Broward County and $381,600 in Miami-Dade, according to the Florida Association of Realtors.
In October median homes prices had dropped to $368,900 in Broward and $366,300 in Miami-Dade, a steep decline from previous months. Indeed, prices in Broward had dropped for two consecutive months before the release of new sales figures showing a sharp price hike in November. And the persistent rise of interest rates, and the fact mortgage rates have creeped higher, led some to think the long-predicted slowdown of the red hot housing market was finally here.
Others, however, attributed the October dip to hurricanes -- particularly Hurricane Wilma -- that battered South Florida and closed businesses for days.
The pundits predicting a return to skyrocketing home prices turned out to be right, at least for now.
South Florida home prices also rose sharply compared to the same period a year earlier. In Miami-Dade November prices were up 31 percent compared November 2004. In Broward the price of a single-family home in November was up 29 percent compared to the same period a year ago.
Meanwhile, the number of homes sold in South Florida remained down in Miami-Dade and Broward counties, a relatively consistent trend throughout the year. November homes sales were down 25 percent in Miami-Dade and 21 percent in Broward, compared to the same period the year before.
The Florida Association of Realtors tracks the median price of existing single-family homes. It does not monitor condominium prices

41cadillac said...

You load sixteen tons, what do you get Another day older and deeper in debt Saint Peter don't you call me 'cause I can't go......

Local condo flippers may be in too deep
By Scott Van Voorhis
Thursday, December 22, 2005 - Updated: 08:52 AM EST

The Hub’s jittery condominium market faces another storm cloud: hundreds of unsold units in new condo towers that brokers and mom-and-pop investors had bought early on in hopes of flipping for quick profits.

Some have exited, as planned, with thousands in windfall profits. But others may not be so lucky amid falling sales and dropping prices in an overloaded condo market, real estate executives say.

Thousands of new condo units, in glitzy downtown towers and modest suburban projects alike, are opening up across the Boston area. And more than 10 percent of these units have been snapped up by investors of various stripes, according to Brian Rugg, who puts out an influential market report at ERA Boston Real Estate Group.

With the market sliding, a flood of condo flips could grease the market’s downward slide, executives warn.

“Putting more supply in a soft market, that obviously would create more volatility in prices on the down side,” said Thomas Meagher, head of Northeast Apartment Advisors.

One project where condo flippers can clearly be seen at work is East Boston’s newly minted Porter 156, a one-time lightbulb factory where loft-style units sell for prices ranging from the high $200,000s to well past $400,000.

Amid this rush to cash out, Rhonda Kelley, a local music publicist, counts herself among the lucky ones, flipping her condo for $439,000 shortly after Porter 156 opened this fall and pocketing more than $100,000. But she winces when she looks at the myriad of online postings from other would-be Porter 156 flippers.

“There are a huge number of flippers,” Kelley said. “If I didn’t close quickly, I would be up against 30 or 40 units in a matter of a week.”

Still, Porter 156 is far from unique, with condo speculators flocking to an array of new Boston towers and projects.

Looking to cash in, Will Montero, a top Boston real estate broker, has created his own condo flip investment pool that includes cash from Ohio doctors, San Francisco investors and overseas financiers.

Over the past three or four years, Montero and his fellow investors have snapped up as many as 40 condos in some of the city’s top new high-rises: Fort Point’s Channel Center, South Boston’s Court Square Press and various Leather District buildings. Some were buy and holds, others quick flips.

Not to mention East Boston’s Porter 156, where Montero finds himself with two units to unload.

But he has no plans to quit flipping, even with signs that the condo market’s best days may be gone.

“It’s a pretty interesting game,” Montero said. “Real estate blows away anything in the stock market for the average investor.”

Anonymous said...

The bubble is deflating and if your someone that's got suckered into variable rate loans by greedy self centered mortgage brokers, well, you better look out. In 1 or 2 years your monthly payments are going to sky rocket.

At this time everyone else will be selling their houses and you wont be able to get rid of your house so quickly. If the family has a hard time, or your a little low on cash, the banks will be happy to foreclose on your house!


Anonymous said...

Read the Facts

Don't listen to money hungry Real Estate and Mortgage Brokers


41cadillac said...

Tennesse Ernie Ford sang it all!!!

Sixteen Tons -author Merle Travis, Sang by Tennesse Ernie Ford
Some people say a man is made outta mud
A poor man's made outta muscle and blood
Muscle and blood and skin and bones
A mind that's a-weak and a back that's strong....
You load sixteen tons, what do you get?
Another day older and deeper in debt
Saint Peter don't you call me 'cause I can't go
I owe my soul to the company store ...
I was born one mornin' when the sun didn't shine
I picked up my shovel and I walked to the mine
I loaded sixteen tons of number nine coal
And the straw boss said "Well, a-bless my soul" ....
You load sixteen tons, what do you get?
Another day older and deeper in debt
Saint Peter don't you call me 'cause I can't go
I owe my soul to the company store .......

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

We have an inverted yeild curve today for the first time since December 2000 acording to Money Magazine.

History says this is the precursor to recession.

Read the article and hear the "experts" tell us it will be different this time. Go ahead and invest.

ColumbusOH said...

Actually, I beg to differ on the opinion of the interest rate. I could not understand most of your logic used to predict the housing crash.

I have been thinking the interest will actually drop in the future as the housing bubble deflate. This is simply economics 101 -- suplly and demand. As demand drop and the supply over demand, interest will drop. This is evidently shown in the yield curve as the interest of the long term 10 year note has been dropping in the past few weeks. Soon, when the FED sees that economy is loosing steam, they will start reducing interest dates to increase demand.

I do not share the reason that housing crash is due to higher interest rates. It will crash due its own weight, that builders over build on false demand signals, and speculators selling on the way down, and high bankcruptcy/deliquency.

Tom said...


Pending recession looms.

Housing prices will plunge.

Tom said...


I agree that interest rates won't be what causes housing prices to decline. But what i will do indirectly is cause demand to fall as you predict.

Once demand falls inventory explodes and housing prices will decrease.

The economy is heading for a correction. The FED will loosen monetary policy, but will the banks be able to absorb the ultra low rates in the face of bankruptcies and Foreclosures?

Urbania said...

All I can say is we're all lucky Florida Real Estate and Real Estate nationwide cannot be easily traded online through the likes of Scottrade and Ameritrade because if real estate traded ..You would see a major correction in a matter of a week. All those condo flippers would be Flipping off there shiny new balconies. On another note Im worried when exsisting Home sales come out December 29. Hold on to Your hats and grab a chair because the music is finally stopping IMHO.

Anonymous said...

fibonacci knew what he was talking about!

mtnrunner2 said...

foxwoodlief - Maybe that's why most analysts go back to the late 1970's when analyzing the trend. If you go back to 1976 in SD, and look at median home price/per capita income, both troughs (1985 and 1998) had a ratio of 9. Now we are at 14.5. Getting back to 9 would require, at current median incomes, a median price of $360,000. You can also look at the difference in rents vs mortgages. Both methods are a way of looking at house prices based on fundamentals, and it makes sense that as fundamentals change, that housing prices change right along with them.

Arioch said...

What do you think will be the "firesale" items as people cling onto their ARM's, stress their stretched home ATM's and watch their minimum CC payments increase...

I see in my crystal ball firesales on:

Cadillac Escalades
Water Jetskis
Dune Buggies (and trailers)
Boats (and trailers)
Porche convertables
Mercedes (all flavors)
Rider mowers
Dodge Ram (all flavors)
High end furniture
Dirt Bikes

These top shelf purchases will go for pennies on the dollar to try to scare up liquidity in order to feed the option-ARM monsters out there.

What else will be in those yard sales?

Richie said...

C'mon, don't disrespect the brand.

It's Porsche.

keith said...

arioch - I'm kinda liking ebay stock - figure people will sell whatever is not bolted down to cover their ever-increasing interest-only ARM mortgage payment before foreclosure

Excessively Diverted said...

I agree with Urbania. Florida is going to be riddled with empty condos. The only thing I can imagine saving the condo industry here is if foreigners keep buying vacation homes in FL but I'm not sure that will be enough. We live in the panhandle and they are continuing to build condo towers all over the place. There are already hundreds of condos on the market that are not selling. Who do they think is going to live in all the new units?

I think single family homes are going to be hit hard here as well. There have been a gazillion speculators in this state. I've noticed quite a few of the flippers throwing their houses on the market hoping to get out ASAP but they're sitting on the market for a long time.

Anonymous said...


Don't forget they can always liquidate those priceless Beany Baby collections, Cabbage Patch dolls, Pok-e-mon cards, Tickle-Me-Elmos, and fake Rolexs they wasted thousands on.

Robert Coté said...

It's "Porsche" pronounced poor-sheh. And it isn't a joke like Target pronounced Thar-ghette. Some of the great Docktor's vehicles have proven to be awesome investments while providing decades of owner satisfaction. Other models?..., well nevermind. Same with primary homeownership. THere are a few parallels worth noting. Both incur carrying costs, taxes, insurance, etc. Both can be used while still being an investment. Actual results are a crapshoot if the intent is to purely make money. Easy to sell in good times, hard/impossible to sell in bad. Both subject to fickle consumer tastes. There is a plus side to both; if you buy carefully and mantain condition over the long run the pleasure you derive day-to-day overrides any financial consideration.

urbania said...

The problem with Real Estate in Florida is not only the price of the Real Estate fueled by flippers is the cost of taxes and Insurance. Many people can afford the sales prices but few can afford the new taxes and Insurance. Since Florida has the Save our home act . Cities can only raise taxes 3 percent max on homesteaded property...when someone buys: taxes are adjusted based on a percentage of sales price. If You own non homesteaded property or You just bought Your screwed. These greedy Counties especially Broward county Florida have raised taxes on investment property nearly triple in the last five years.(Still the same caliber of service as five years ago) Practically forcing landlords to have to sell . These idiots dont know that they have fueled the affordable housing crunch. If Your a Landlord in Many Florida Cities You work for the City.

Regarding all the new Condos being built accross Florida ..Many say dont worry foreign buyers are coming or People are moving to Florida. People have always been moving to sunny Florida and foreigners have been buying,but with all these condos going up Youd think that an entire foreign country is closing up shop and moving to Florida.
Used Home sales out in the A.M wont be to pretty should take the stock market down a peg. This report IMHO will not be the one to finally wake up the Real Estate Dreamers but when the report comes out next month it will be really ugly and Business weeks Hot property blogs name should change to Dont touch property with a ten foot pole blog.

foxwoodlief said...

Here is the latest on Austin from the Austin Statesman

Austin home market surges; November median is an all-time high
Home market surges even as supply drops; November median price hits an all-time high
By Kate Miller Morton
Tuesday, December 20, 2005

Central Texas home buyers shrugged off rising interest rates in November, sending sales up 24 percent and the median price to an all-time high of $170,000, up 15 percent. But the supply of homes fell sharply, to a four-year low, and homes in some areas are selling within days, sometimes with multiple offers.

The hot markets include Southwest Austin, close-in East Austin, and South and Northwest neighborhoods. In East Austin, the number of sales is up 146 percent so far this year, and the median price is up more than 40 percent, to $155,000.

Trojans feel right at home in Rose Bowl
Fizer, Emmett adjusting to minor-league life with Austin Toros
Vatican rethinking tradition of limbo
Former city worker charged in new sexual assault case
Stickers cause Capital Metro crackdown
Sandy Kerr, an agent with Keller Williams Realty, recently listed a house for $199,950 in the Shady Hollow subdivision of Southwest Austin. Two days later, she said, she had a contract and a backup contract, both for well above the asking price.

Houses that are priced well "seem to fly off the market," she said, though fast sales don't necessarily translate into big price jumps. Prices in the Southwest market rose just 1 percent last month, with a median of $223,000.

Sales have been strong all year. But until last month, prices had been rising at a more moderate pace. Through November, the median price is up 6 percent from the same 11 months of 2004.

Even in some areas where homes are selling fast, prices haven't been shooting up. But sales are growing much faster at the upper price ranges, helping drive up the median price.

Sales of homes priced between $100,000 and $150,000 are up about 11 percent, while sales of homes priced at $1 million and up are 50 percent higher than a year ago, though only 20 homes fall into that category.

Bill Stanberry, Stanberry & Associates CEO, said he thinks demand is just one element fueling rising median prices.

"The median simply means a lot of the lower-priced homes weren't sold or weren't there to buy in November, and so the people bought higher-dollar homes," he said.

"That may be a reflection of the interest rates ticking up," he said, adding that rising mortgage interest rates have a bigger impact on buyers who may be stretching to afford houses than on more affluent people.

Mortgage rates have risen to an average of 6.3 percent, up from about 5.7 percent at the beginning of the year, according to Freddie Mac, the federal mortgage finance company.

Through November, area sales were up 19 percent, and the median was up 5 percent, to $163,000. But new listings have decreased all year, tightening the market for buyers.

"Austin is doing very well," said Jim Gaines, research economist with the Real Estate Center at Texas A&M University. "I don't know if you can say it's the leading market in the state, but it's definitely the leading market among the major four: Austin, San Antonio, Houston and Dallas."

Austin's momentum is bucking the national trend, according to Walter Molony, spokesman for the National Association of Realtors.

"We are seeing a slowing in home sales, but not in prices," Molony said of the national market. "Prices are continuing to rise at historically high rates. We expect price appreciation to slow down in 2006, but still rise a little faster than historic norms."

Home prices have been relatively flat in Central Texas for several years, keeping homeownership in reach for a larger share of the market than in many East and West coast areas.

Austin's third quarter median price was $167,100, a 5.4 increase from the year before. The national median was $215,900, a 14.7 percent increase from the third quarter 2004.

Central Texas could see a much higher rate of appreciation next year if the new listings fail to keep up with demand. But many agents say they think the lack of new houses on the market is partly attributable to the traditional slowdown around the holidays, when owners are reluctant to show their houses.

"Buyers don't seem to be seasonal, but the sellers do," said Carol Strickland, president of Avenue One Properties.

kmorton@statesman.com; 445-3641

wreckingball said...

Here's an article from today's NY Times that suggests homes are actually affordable.


Arioch said...

Gotta love it: check this article out...


"Sales of previously owned homes fell 1.7% in November as inventories hit their highest point in more than 19 years..."

Then you have to add the disclaimers on the bottom....

Even with the sales drop, economists said the housing market remains in healthy shape and is on track to set record-high home sales for the fifth year in a row for all of 2005.

"We are really on track for a soft landing," said David Lereah, the association's chief economist. Moderately rising mortgage rates are allowing the housing market thus far to land safely, he said. "There are no balloons popping," he said.

Anonymous said...

The sheer amount of discussion regarding a housing bubble has convinced me we are in one. Just yesterday I was at an airport in the CNBC shop looking at magazines and heard an interview on "Kudlow and Co" about how there is no housing boom.

I remember lots of disucssion about the stock market soft landing towards the mid/end of 2000.

Housing is talked about so much that it's impossible not to be in a bubble, be it physical or expected. It's toast, the goose is cooked, and batten down the hatches and hang on.

Arioch said...

Here is a great rundown on the Vegas dot-condo craze and status listing all the projects, status, prices etc...


jmc said...

This list of most overvalued (and undervalued) housing markets came out today on CNNMoney, for what it's worth. Top of the list (with the percentage over what the median priced home should be valued, according to the authors of the report):

Naples, FL +84%
Merced, CA +77%
Salinas, CA +75%
Port St. Lucie, FL +72%
Stockton, CA +72%
Madera, CA +70%
Santa Barbara, CA +70%
Modesto, CA +67%
Napa, CA +65%
Riverside, CA +65%
Medford, OR +64%
Sacramento, CA +61%
Atlantic City, NJ +59%
Chico, CA +59%
Fresno, CA +58%
West Palm Beach, FL +57%
Redding, CA +56%
Santa Rosa, CA +56%
Bend, OR +56%
Sarasota, FL +56%
Miami, FL +55%
Oxnard, CA +55%
Vero Beach, FL +54%
Los Angeles, CA +54%
Fort Lauderdale, FL +53%
Vallejo, CA +53%
San Luis Obispo, CA +53%

The Thinker said...


If houses loose a lot of value in a short period of time I guess thats a hard landing.

What's a soft landing? If the same houses loose the same value over the next 10 years?

That doesent sound any better to me.

Anonymous said...

The MEDIA has a love affair with that economist from the real estate trade group. Why must they feel the need to take his word for what is going on? For example he was interviewed on NBC. Don't they know that he is an industry schill who will bend the facts in favor of the real estate industry? It reminds me of the MEDIA rushing to get the opinion of Ms. Lundburg on gasoline. She like the real estate economist is just an industry hack.

Note the consistency of that RE economist's comments. Before he said there was NO housing bubble. Then once the negative data came out he said it will be a "soft landing" which got parroted by every pundit in the MEDIA and other stooge economists. How the hell does he know it will be a "soft landing"? He is simply trying to bend the psychology of the moment.

Sorry but I see it as a HARD landing due to the panic driven exodus of the speculators which creates a self feeding downward sprial.

At least in today's article in the Chicago Tribune, one economist called the situation correctly by saying the market peaked in June and that according to his study the prices will fall in 2006.... across the country due to rising rates and the quite shutting down of the creative financing deals. To bad the other MEDIA groupies do not interview him or have him debate the RE industry economist schill!

keith said...

loved this quote:

People aren't really shopping prices," said Bill Trask, a broker at Coldwell Banker Friends and Neighbors Realty in suburban Portland. "They're shopping payments."

in other words:

"uh, duh, I don't care what the price of the asset is - I just care what my debt service is"


I never in my life thought such reckless and stupid economic behavior.

Never underestimate the fiscal stupidity of your countrymen. Another failure of our education system?

wreckingball said...

From today's Portland Press-Herald:

December 30, 2005

Hot housing market may be losing steam

By BETH QUIMBY, Portland Press Herald Writer

Dino and Mia DeSanctis, with their son Ryan, 4, bought a house in Gorham four months ago, but their Portland home, in background, has yet to sell despite a $20,000 price reduction.

For the past four months, Dino and Mia DeSanctis have mowed two lawns, shoveled two driveways and paid two mortgages, two heating bills and two property tax bills.

Owners of a new home in Gorham and their old home in Portland, the couple is among a number of southern Maine homeowners caught in a slowing real estate market. The DeSanctises bought their new house when prices were peaking, and have twice dropped the price on their Portland home, with no buyers in sight.

"Without a doubt, it is the most stressful situation we have been in," said Mia DeSanctis, a stay-at-home mother of one.

Gone are the days of bidding wars and open houses that draw dozens of shoppers. The five-year boom in housing appears to have peaked. Nationally, sales of existing homes dipped by 1.7 percent in November compared with the year before, the National Association of Realtors re- ported Thursday.

In the Northeast, sales declined 2.7 percent. In Massachusetts - often a bellwether for Maine - single-family home sales dropped 9.2 percent in November compared with a year earlier, the second straight month of declines, according to the Massachusetts Association of Realtors.

In Maine, sales dipped 4 percent in October compared with a year earlier. November sales statistics were not available Thursday.

And with the inventory of homes for sale up and the number of buyers down, prices are beginning to soften, brokers say.

As a result, said Lynn O'Leary, broker and co-owner of O'Leary and Saxby in Gorham, buyers have many more choices and can be more aggressive in their offers than in the frenzied market of the past.

Last year at this time there were only 10 homes in the highly sought-after $200,000 to $300,000 price range in Gorham, she said. This year there are 60.

"There is so much to choose from, buyers can decide things like, 'I like the landscaping better on this one or the painting more on this one,' " she said.

Julie Rowland, who just closed on her first home in Westbrook, had been watching the market and jumped in during November when it appeared prices had softened. Of the 25 to 30 properties she looked at, only a handful have sold, she said.

"I felt I had time to look around," said Rowland, who is single and an assistant manager at a clothing store.

She ended up paying $169,000 for a two-bedroom condominium after getting the seller to shave several thousand dollars off the asking price.

"I felt like I got a very good price, if not a deal," she said.

Not all brokers are convinced the market is on a downward trend. They point to home prices that continued to rise nationally, despite the sales slowdown. In Maine, home prices continued to rise in October.

John Hatcher of the Hatcher Group, part of Keller Williams Realty in Portland, said he is not so sure the slowdown will last long. He said a $650,000 home in Scarborough that went on the market Thanksgiving weekend lasted for only a week.

"We have had four properties go under since Friday," he said.

But many sellers said the market is not what it was last year.

Gerard Cote delayed a move to Messina, N.Y., while he waited for his condominium at Meadowbrook West in Gorham to sell. He said that last year, units at Meadowbrook sold in 48 hours by word of mouth. His condo was on the market for four months, and he came down $20,000 before he finally sold it for $245,000.

His advice to would-be sellers: "Spruce up their homes, and if there are any repairs they better do that now. "

Mia DeSanctis said she and her husband were not looking to move when they drove by an open house in Gorham last summer and fell in love with the house.

The owners were not accepting offers that were contingent on the sale of the buyer's house. And the market was so hot then that the couple worried they would lose the Gorham house to another buyer, she said.

Their real estate agent assured them that their Portland home, priced at $279,000, just $1,000 less than their new home, would sell quickly.

"The day we put it on the market, it died," DeSanctis said. Since then they have lowered the price twice, to $259,000. At one point they had an interested family, but negotiations broke off after that family was in a bad traffic accident.

The last potential buyer toured the house three weeks ago. DeSanctis is now contemplating taking a job to help pay the bills.

"And that is what we were trying to avoid," she said.

Staff Writer Beth Quimby can be contacted at 791-6363 or at:


Jay of Brunswick, me
Dec 30, 2005 9:21 AM
There is no question that inventories are building up and homes are staying longer on the market. Price reductions are becoming more commonplace and it is likely that buyers are becoming very cautious, very likely in anticipation of further reductions. Furthermore, the change in psychology is being hastened by tremendous talk of a bursting housing bubble in the national media.

Interest rates have gone up tremendously and will likely tick up. In many markets such as Florida and California the escalating home prices and increased interest rates have outgrown incomes and those markets are very much slowing down. Panicking buyers, often times speculators, willing to pay anything have now begun to be replaced by panicking sellers.

The problems seen in such markets have also begun to manifest themselves, but to lesser degree, in Boston and NY. According to the Housing Market Analysis released yesterday by National City Corp, Boston is 18% overvalued and NY is 27% overvalued. Other nearby markets such as Providence and Nassau-Suffolk are even more overvalued at 35% and 43% respectively.

The same survey places Portland as 29% overvalued. However, it is possible and probably somewhat likely that Portland will be spared the type of freefall in prices envisioned elsewhere. This is due to several factors. One of these factors is that Portland's buying has not been heavily driven by speculators or "flippers". Secondly, Portland does not have as many rentals available as many other markets. Also, Portland is still an affordable market compared to places like Boston and New York, historically sources of Portland transplants. A homeowner in greater Boston can sell his $1,000,000 home and get something comparable in Portland for perhaps half that. So even if the Boston residence can now only fetch $950,000 - the prices in Portland are still quite attractive.

This last factor is likely to become more important as the baby boom starts retiring in earnest. Those at the boom's vanguard were born in 1946 and have just reached the age of 59 and 1/2 where they can tap into their IRA's without penalty. While many will stay put, and many will seek warmer climates, enough will come to Maine to pressure home prices. Many are already familiar with Maine's quality of life from vacations spent here.

Finally, another trend that augurs well for more out of state transplants is telecommuting. The Internet has only been mainstream for 10 years or so and society has yet to fully digest what it empowers. As the digestive process continues, more people will live where they want to live as opposed to where all the jobs have historically been.

All of this said, any slowdown in sales or declines in Portland area home prices will probably be short lived - maybe one or two years. The overall trend should be upward.

Vacation properties throughout the state could be an altogether different story. Many of these sales are speculative, particularly houselots and condos at ski areas. Also, if things get tough, these types of properties will flood the market before primary residences will. Developments where lots are 99% "sold out" may sprout crops of for sale signs when the first hint of a slowdown reveals many of those "sold" lots were simply being held by investors.

Andrew of South Portland, ME
Dec 30, 2005 9:08 AM

The above link was posted a few days ago and shows the percentage above or under of the market value of housing in the United States.

Portland comes in at 34th place at +29%, while Manchester, NH comes in at 40th at +23%.
That ranks Portland 4th in the ME/MA/NH area and Manchester at 6th.
Do the math and you'll see it adds a fairly significant amount to the price of a house.

Hopefully, and I say that with much skepticism, the market will come down and housing will be an option, not a wishful thought along with winning the lottery.

sandy of portland, me
Dec 30, 2005 8:59 AM
I find it interesting that at the end of the real estate boom developers are planning on building hundreds of $500,000+ condos in Portland. The city goverment seems to think this is positive developement. Portland will become a sanctuary for the wealthy. At least there will be lots of jobs shining there shoes.

Fat Tubbo of Winthrop, ME
Dec 30, 2005 8:42 AM
Like the stock market, the housing market also works in cycles. I feel the Maine housing market can no longer sustain these unaffordable highs. I feel the housing market in Maine, and pretty much throughout the country, has gone past the peakof being in the oversold state. Now, the market needs time to recover. How much time will be dependent on how fast wages take to catch up as well as how low the interest rates can stay.

I also question how a family of four with a median income of, say, $50K can afford a $250K home. I look around me here in Wintrhop, with a median income of something like $35K and the median home price somewhere around $150K, and also have to wonder how young families are able to make ends meet with such high mortgages and such low incomes.

Frank of POrtland, ME
Dec 30, 2005 8:38 AM
Prices are falling and opportunity awaits the patient buyer. People that bought real estate using 3,5, and 7 year adjustable mortgages are going to be burned in the next few years. As a real estate investor I have been waiting for this to happen for the last four years. Its the same old addage buy low and sell high. The real estate market is like the national economy, cyclical. The foreclosure market is going to be red hot over the next two years. Those that were patient enough to buy will reap the rewards of the stupid.

Patrice Goodwin of Wilkes-Barre, PA
Dec 30, 2005 8:37 AM

I grew up in Southern Maine. My husband grew up in the Cleveland suburbs. We will be retiring in a few years. We are both pastors and have served in rural NY and PA, living in parsonages for our whole career. We are planning to purchase a retirement home in the next few years. We would both LOVE to retire in Maine. When I was visiting in Maine last summer I began looking at property. I was astounded at the high price of real estate. I would be very pleased to see the high real estate prices come down so that we are not completely priced out of the market! Otherwise we will probably retire here in Wilkes-Barre PA where the real estate is much more reasonable. Maine is our first choice and its makes me sad that people of moderate means have such a hard time finding housing there.

kk of Gray, ME
Dec 30, 2005 8:26 AM
The rise in housing prices appears to be slowing down. I have been helping a friend look for a home in the under-$200,000 range for over 2 years. There used to be only half a dozen or so for sale in the area she was looking in, and they were too small or basically uninhabitable without thousands of dollars of work. Now there are over 50, and they are large enough for her family and in good condition.

Even though it's not necessarily good news for us homeowners from an equity standpoint, I'm glad that more people will be able to buy a home as the prices stabilize and/or lower. It's sad that some people with household incomes higher than the national average are unable to afford a home in Maine.

Richard of lewiston, me
Dec 30, 2005 8:11 AM
heres a little secret in one word...Lewiston.
we brought a very cool house in Lewiston for under a 100,000. Right in town! Lewiston reminds me of Portland in 1970. Raw and Urban. Empty warehouses everywhere. Soon Lewiston will be full of poets, painters and dancers. Just like Portland in 1975.

Barb of Westbrook, ME
Dec 30, 2005 8:01 AM
I think it is slowing for all but the lower end of the market. There are some great lower end priced condos coming up in Westbrook this year. But the $250,000+ market is slowing for sure!

angie of scarborough, me
Dec 30, 2005 7:33 AM
being a renter right now looking for a home here in scarborough is an un touchable goal. even the land alone is too expensive, this is forcing us to look in other areas away from here. evemn topsham is a little too expensive. houses that are 2 bedrooms with half baths are selling for ridiculous prices like 214,000. i remember a MOBILE HOME a trailer in scarborough sold for 199,000! so much for affordable housing. that isn't in the slums. we have tried several times to purchase a home me a preschool teacher and my other half a full time paramedic/firefighter for the city we are unable to afford even $136,000 home. with our income. we are forced to stay renters and throw our money out the window until the housing market busts.


keith said...

wrecking ball - thanks for posting. here's a part that made me cringe:

"Without a doubt, it is the most stressful situation we have been in," said Mia DeSanctis, a stay-at-home mother of one.

Gone are the days of bidding wars and open houses that draw dozens of shoppers.

There are going to be so many stories of people buying at the top, getting in over their head (interest only no down etc), trying to sell, but finding no buyer. then having to drop the price to sell (and stop the payment that they can't afford) - and take the loss (and go bankrupt possibly)

All they did was do what the media and Bob Toll and the NAR was telling them to do - get a home. Live the American dream. Stop paying rent.

And that one decision, after a lifetime of work in many cases, causes their financial ruin.

So sad.

Anonymous said...

The fat lady's belting out the death scene now.

I nominate this as the most definitive sign of The Top:


The New York Daily News, citing unnamed Republicans, reported Friday that Trump, the billionaire real estate developer and TV personality, is considering a run for governor as a Republican.


World's most notorious and famous real estate investor is getting out. Hmm.........

Decision-Juno-Online-Services-Inc-V-Roberto-Iza said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Hi Keith;

I really like your blog. I have to ask you a stupid question. I am a person that has been renting my entire life. I have been saving long and hard to buy my first home. Gathering from what I am reading about your blog, it seems I should wait the market out. Do you have any recommendations for first time homebuyers who need a place to live?

foxwoodlief said...

Anonymus, I didn't say the bill passed yet. It has failed for three years. That is why a law suit was file and challenged school funding and the Texas Supreme court ruled that funding schools only through property tax was unconstitutional and instructed the state legislature to pass a new bill correcting this deficiency or that schools will not be allowed to open in August 2006. The legislatrue is suppose to meet in Jan to try and work out a deal. The Democrats have been obstructionist in the battle with Republicans and neither party seems willing to do what is in the best interest of the taxpayers of Texas or schools. The high cost of property taxes is the most regressive form of taxation and the most counter-productive. This is why Texas ranks near the bottome for home ownership. The fact that there is the possiblity of reform and a significant reduction in property taxes bode well for the market in Texas. If Texas can escape any significant home price run up and the speculative plague that has hit other prime markets and stay with the healthy PE ratios for rents, Income to mortage ratios, and normal iinflation adjusted annual return (which is in effect a zero increase and zero decrease) then this tax reform makes homes even more affordable.

Texas has some 22 million people. It is continuously growing and is in the sunbelt. It is home to three of the largest cities in the country. It has a diversified state economy and oil, ports, beaches, agriculture, high tech, telecommunications, manufacturing. Texas has a NORMAL economy not built purely on Real Estate like Phoenix. It has absorbed a lot of people from New Orleans reducing bloated inventories of apartments in Houston and a lesser degree in other Texas cities. People will move to Texas to LIVE not to Speculate. Austin is a Great city to live and an influx of people and money will help the cities over all economy which is currently growing naturally and whose High tech industry is much healthier than in 2000. Recently an office building in Austin sold for $245 a sq ft, the highest price for any commercial space in Texas. Samsung is building a new fab plant, the office vacancy and retail space vacancies rates have dropped to healthy levels compared to the bubble of 2000. Though rents for commercial and retail and housing are rising they haven't risen enought to over stimulate speculative building. Coming at the end of a bi-coastal bubble they are better poised to prevent the same thing happening there as lenders and builder position themselves to prevent further bubble induced losses. With a lot of people cashing out of their high priced homes in other markets and using that cash to move to Austin with substantial down payments on high quality homes that will insulate them better against any price declines. Would you rather buy a 3300 sq foot home on a large lot with all the bells and whistles for $330,000 or less and put $200,000 down and have a $130,000 mortgage at 6.5% fixed for 30 or even less at 15 years? Or even (for those lucky enough to really have cashed out of CA or Florida) and pay cash and have no mortgage? What city will suffer more? Las Vegas? Phoenix or other cities in the bubble markets where people bought high and have no options but to live like the Japanese for the next 15 years paying off their over-inflated notes?

So, if any investors read this, beware. Texas is not for dummies. The market is unique. There are plenty of homes at affordable prices that you can't buy and flip fast and make a killing nor buy and charge excessive rents to cover you 0 down investment. Until the tax bill is passed next year you will have very high tax bills on top of any other carrying costs. The benefit of any tax reduction won't be in effect until 2007 tax year and won't be actualized until that bill comes due Jan 1, 2008. Texas and Austin are for those individuals who are tired of their over-priced cities and are looking for a better quality of life and who buy to LIVE in their home in Texas. Those who think they can do a Phoenix flip will be burned. No city in Texas is building 60,000 houses a year or experiencing 100,000 new residents a year to push up demand.

Austin Metro is 1.2 mil and Austin about 680.000. The market has plenty of housing units, only 6600 realtors and many neighborhoods that won't be appreciating at even 1% a month. The hot neighborhoods are still high for Austin and Texas and can still suffer a price reduction as people look to the new areas of Austin that are "hot" and "affordable" and price concious. If you can buy new 9 miles from downtown in South or SW or SE Austin for $105 a sq ft or less you'd have to be crazy to buy in the old "hot" areas of 2000 where homes go for up to $500 a sq ft and need a lot of updating. As in any market you need to evaluate value, location, distance from employment and competition. That large Master Planned community is a sure loser as you'll be competing with new build for up to ten years. But if you look for quality at prices per sq ft that are near the historic norm adjusted for inflation and a home and not an investment then Texas has many viable options to those seeking a better quality of life.

Wednesday, December 28, 2005 8:37:24 PM

foxwoodlief said...
To Anonymous interested in Austin: Febuary is an intersting time to go to Austin. You'll find many things about Austin you'll like. Normally the weather is temperate, you'll be in Cedar Pollen season so if you have allergies, a good try out to see if you can tolerate the pollen. You'll still have lots of trees (mostly the oaks) with leaves but some brown grass. You'll love the Air Port and it continues to expand service across the country with, I think I read recently, to Boston and NY City. The city has quite a few distinct areas. I-35 divides the city in half with the western half part of the hill country and the eastern half part of the black praire. The river divides the city into North and South. Immediatlly south if very desirable with Barton Springs and Travis heights and priced accordingly. Very bohemian in these parts. Just north is downtown and Tarrytown and around Lamar are really great neighborhoods. To th NE of downtown the hottest area is Frenchman's place and other parts of East (traditionally the hispanic/african american side of Austin) are gentrifying and light rai is headed into that area as well (light rail from leander to East Austin is ready to start construction). Ben White (US 71) further seperates South Austin and this area south of Ben While has some great and affordable 80s homes and immediately south of Ben White between S. Congress and Lamar is really interesting and heating up but you can still find homes for around $90 a sq ft. SW Austin from Circle ranch (very large Master planned community) north to the River offers great older neighborhoods and easy access to town. This area is where a lot of interest has shifted over the past several years and is where a lot fo Silicon business are expanding, especially around the OakHill and SW Parkway areas. Newer homes here are a great buy. I bought off 71 on the way to Bee Cave just inside the Austin City limits so close to Lakeway and Austin in a small, master planned community of around 300 homes that is just about built out. It has been under construction for the last four years and struggled during the .com bust and the sluggish real estate market that Austin has experience the past six years. Lakeway is a great upscale area but is 28 miles from town though it is on the shores of Lake Travis. The NW Hills has always been hot as has the area around Mt Bonnel (NW) but prices are high and homes dated and the area has grown so much the past 10 years that it is becoming extremely congested and you pay for location rather than value. The far north is still struggling and suffering from the uncontrolled growth of the 90s and though many homes are inexpensive they are not in areas that are as nice as the NW Hills or South/SW Austin or Lakeway. Austin does suffer some of the worst congestion for a mid-size city with a few years still to go before some of the current highway improvements provide some relief. If you choose to buy north be prepared to pay for those "values" in long commutes. During rush hour I-35 North is a parking lot for 20 miles to Georgetown.

Some of the smaller communites within 28 miles that offer low cost homes are Lockhart, San Marcos, Georgetown, Taylor, Elgin, Bastrop. These are definitely "Texas" towns with the same conservative bent that Texas is famous for. Central Austin, NW Hills, South Austin tend to be the Liberal areas most associated with Austin that distinquishes Austin from the rest of Texas.

Taylor has a lot of old historic homes but economically depressed and one must commute to find employment. Lockhart is similar (but to the SE) and has great potential if it every finds a local economy to boost the area out of poverty. Bastrop is growing but very conservative and quiet. San Marcos 40 miles south of Austin adn 50 miles North of San Antonio is a great area, growing (even if the city is fighting growth every step of the way) and home to a Texas University (LBJs alma mater) not economically depressed, has a great spring and historic square and homes but most people have to commute to San Antonio or Autstin for employement.

Hope that gives you a point of reference to start your visit to Austin. Oh, and visit South Congress, the 6th street Entertainment district, the warehouse district near Lamar for a sense of culture and a horse drawn carriage ride through downtown to see the Capital and the historic areas is worth the money for a taste of Austin.

foxwoodlief said...

Here is a cut from a blog from Austrailia to help put the US bubble in perspective. As I've mentioned in some of my blog comments no one wants to compare the US economy and house bubble to other world markets or establish a true base price for homes. If we exercise caution and learn from the mistakes of other countries we can quickly recover from an fizzle in local bubbles.

From Australia:

Housing wealth versus income and total wealth
Non-financial assets (mainly housing)
% household disposable income % total household wealth
Australia 628 68
Canada 288 46
Germany 340 56
Japan 392 44
UK 448 52
US 241 37
Source: OECD, ABS, Datastream, AMP Capital Investors

While there has been talk recently of a housing bubble in the US it takes only 350 weeks of average wages to buy an average house in the US versus 500 weeks in Australia (ignoring tax). The relatively expensive nature of Australian housing does not appear to be explained by home ownership rates, tax breaks, house size or holiday homes – these are all similar or “better” in the US. While our tendency to congregate in large cities may be a factor, the expensive nature of Australian housing is more likely to be due to the fact that Australian housing is very overvalued after an extended bubble.

Anonymous said...

The obvious way to avoid losing money in the bubble is not to buy real estate right now.

But what are good ways to make money? Keep cash, and buy when blood is running in the streets is the standard answer.

What else?

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

My retail store front rent just went up 32.5% today in Pasadena California.
I know some of the other merchants in my area have been feeling the pinch of the slowing economy and slugish retain sales.
I expect vacancies to start poping up.

41cadillac said...

It is a matter of perspective. Those home owners and flippers were and are pleased with the outrageous increase in the assessed value of their homes.

But, But, when gasoline was approaching $3.00 a gallon Ohhhh did they yell and holler fowl play.

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

Good point on OIL!

Google this

"L-A-T-O-C" stands for LifeAfterTheOilCrash.net

Anonymous said...

I heard some real estate doctor says that there will be a little blip in activity and then we will be back into steady gains!

Go ahead and invest before it is too late!!!

Dogcrap Green said...

Mister Anonymous,

you wrote

Why is it that whenever I see a local newspaper print an article about the bubble busting 2006 I see the same basic story?

-"The dramatic increase in real estate prices was due primarily to low interest rates and now that interest rates have gone up, sales have slowed down"

I to am also puzzle by this. expessially due to the fact mortgage rates have been dropping. But don't let that stop the experts at Forbes from explaining their theories.

When mortgage rates hit 5.5% on a 30 year loan, do you think it will stun a few experts?

Anonymous said...

Well, there is still hope for housing in Fort Collins, Colorado (Intel, HP, Woodward Governor...but Celestica is leaving)

Check out the listings here:

For example, check out this bargain near CSU:


000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

Our country deferred the last recession by propping up the economy with real estate. The longer we defer the natural progression the bigger the eventual bill. It does not matter who takes office next, they will not have the ability to bail us out. Bernanke is a fall guy who will take the blame for the BURN.

Anonymous said...

I passed a condo project on Phillipe Pkwy in Safety Harbor, Fl. This is a "small town" north of St. Petersburg. This condo - for those who are interested - is not new. It looks to be 5 years old or older. Anyway, there are quite a few For Sale signs next to the street. It looks like a nice place, but I doubt I could afford it - yet.

keith said...

From http://www.truecontrarian.com/

U.S. REAL ESTATE: LOOK FOR THE FIRST TRUE NATIONWIDE COLLAPSE OF U. S. REAL ESTATE IN ITS HISTORY (December 26, 2005): U.S. housing prices in many markets have more than doubled in the past five years, even as U.S. rents have only moved up with inflation. In spite of this fact, a fairly substantial number of financial analysts are not expecting a significant decline in real estate valuations because "it has never happened before on a nationwide scale". What these folks always fail to consider is that there have never been interest-rate-only mortgages and negative-amortization mortgages before, either, in any part of the world, at any time in its history. Japan had the closest thing, with 100-year mortgages in the late 1980s; its real estate thereafter declined 60% nationwide (collapsing even more in some previously "hot" neighborhoods). Just today, at a nearby realtor's office, I saw a sign in huge letters: "40-Year Mortgages!", as though they were a sure path to wealth. Caveat emptor! One third of all mortgages in 2005 were of the negative amortization variety, meaning that buyers' total mortgage debt increases each month, rather than decreasing, as was formerly the case back in the "old days" (meaning before 2003!). Touts for mortgage companies such as Countrywide Financial frequently boast about how their innovative products are making it possible for anyone to buy the house of their dreams. They're absolutely correct--which is exactly why the housing market is so dangerous. Already, inventory in the U.S. is at a 20-year high nationwide, and at a 30-year high in many cities, while new home prices have been falling for several months--4% just in the past month, according to this week's offical government data. It's just a matter of one year, two at the most, before "60 Minutes" runs a segment on how honest, sincere, working-class Americans were misled by devious, greedy mortgage brokers into getting a negative-amortization loan, and how they have therefore been led to the brink of bankruptcy. Also expect this kind of media coverage of the real estate collapse by the end of 2006: "Denver's real estate market is down 15% in the past year; Las Vegas is down 20%; Phoenix, an incredible drop of 30%. Will your town be next?" The accompanying photos will, of course, show residential blocks with a "For Sale" sign on more than half of the lawns, with a few aerial shots of large condominium projects--ideally, with a few key elements that are obviously not completely constructed--in foreclosure

keith said...

saw this hilarious post at http://www.goldismoney.info/forums/showthread.php?p=161809#post161809

"Its only been a year since the Kerry and Bush signs went down and now it appears there is a new election. The candidate's name appears to be "For Sale" and it seems like everybody around here supports him! He must be running against "For Rent" because I see a lot of those signs too, but not as many as for the other guy. Anyone heard of these candidates, or know what they stand for?"

Arioch said...

I think this is a great time to see if we can come up with new loan products to extend the current "Good Times" (tm).

I would like to propose a new mortgage product.


It would be the Option ARM & LEG.

The All New Option ARM & LEG loan
The Option ARM part is standard, you know you don't really pay anything. But the LEG part would bolster the 2nd part of the equation.

LEG = Liquidizing Equity Generator.

The LEG would make your mortgage automatically refinance every 12 months. All costs associated would automatically roll into the principal.

Since real estate never goes down (kind of like the wife after being married for 10+ years), the value of the property only goes up.

Thus your mortgage would actually pay you to live in your house with never ending equity extraction.

The principal would simply grow and not be paid until:

A) The last day of the 30 year loan, when your 250k mortgage would leave a principal of between 4 and 12 million dollars to be paid.

B) Your credit score doesn't allow the "auto refi", in which case the current balance (referred to as "massive deficit") would amortize over the balance of the loan (30 years less time spent).

C) Property value stops appreciating (see option (B)). Of course this would never happen.

You can chose to have a check sent to you, or convenient vouchers for exciting gifts like granite countertops, Humvees, Pools, Granite Garage Floors or even as Home Depot gift cards.


Any other great ideas to make the good times keep rolling?

Anonymous said...

Study the history of irish feudal landlords or watch the film "The Field", you'll have some idea of the basis for Ireland's current obsession with owning property.

Malaise in old europe, low interest rates, parental subsidies, shills, opaque real-estate laws, speculators, panic buying, government medling and corruption have led to a property buying binge on par with Tokyo circia 1985.

In the 5 October issue of Ireland's Sunday Business Post, Economist David McWilliams put together an excellent commentary and analysis of the Irish property bubble, what we can learn from Japan's property boom and bust and how the current real-estate bubble is harming Ireland's long-term competitiveness.

The article

Anonymous said...

Why have housing stocks gone up ever since this blog started?

thanks for your wisdom

keith said...

last anon - nice try. check out


invest in housing stocks, mortgage bankers, home improvement stores.

or just take your cash into the backyard and burn it.

Anonymous said...

Woo Hoo!

Fannie Mae (FNM) shares jumped more than 9 percent, hitting an intraday high of $53.60 -- a price not seen since August. The stock at midday traded up $4.54, or 9.3 percent, at $53.29 on the New York Stock Exchange.

Anonymous said...

Check out these stocks since 11/23 (that is the date Keith asked us to follow his stock advice):

Sell Short:


If you had done the exact opposite of what Keith said, you would have made money on EACH ONE of these stocks.


Anonymous said...

written in november.....

everyone_calm_down said...
The blog author says:

"1) Sell all of your personal real estate.
2) Short homebuilders, lenders, Fannie and Freddie, home furnishing retailers and mortgage insurance companies
3) Raise cash and put into 4%+ saving"

I'd like the author of this blog to put his money where his mouth is and tell us what he would do with a $10,000 investment. Using today's 11/23 prices (market has closed for holiday), where would the blog author invest 10k today? Please give us specifics (stocks/shares/prices/long or short/etc.....this way we can see how good this guy really is and see if anything he says has any merit.

Wednesday, November 23, 2005 2:49:45 PM

Housing Panic said...
For the 10k:

$5000 - 4% interest savings at HSBC
$1000 - short FNM
$1000 - short TOL
$1000 - short TGIC
$1000 - short SPF
$1000 - long COP

Please track those puppies and enjoy

Anonymous said...

These posts have a twinge of 'Schadenfreude' to them if you ask me. Why wish the market to crash and the home owners suffer? Because prices went out of control? All most want is a place for their familes and place to stay in , not flip. Well at least most people I know. Prices are what they are, what are you going to do? This is going from Housing Panic to Renter Panic.

Dogcrap Green said...

Housing Panic,

You are taking some pretty tough hits here.

I tried telling that despite suburbs being over proced in many markets. Home builders would thrive.

You lost money for anyone that listen to you in November.

I have during this time as documented by my housing boom blog.

Just curious if you notice the nice downward slid of Mortgage rates all through December?

Don't beat yourself up though. All other blogger that screamed "Short the Home Builders" are looking just as dumb.

keith said...

is everyone here running a sprint or a race? does anyone seriously think COP won't be much higher a year from now? two years from now? 10 years from now?

Does anyone seriously think the homebuilders and lenders will thrive in a massive downturn?

and anyone anonymous flaming is gutless. post your name so we can mock you in a few months

oh, FNM popped up on bogus news - rudman came out in the afternoon and corrected the bloomberg misquote that originally popped the stock.

Anonymous said...

Last anon,
Those whose property future beliefs run counter to CW don't wish the average home owner financial harm. An average home owner should be able to ride out a crash/correction in their own home. We do wish to warn those in denial that there is a downside risk and that they should put themselves underwater and assume the tide will help them float.

I reserve my Schadenfreude for the speculators, dishonest real estate agents, easy money speculators, corrupt apraisers and mortgage bankers who give away bad loans as though they were Santa Claus. Most of these folks deserve a good spanking.

an_dochasach said...

Last anon,
Those whose property future beliefs run counter to CW don't wish the average home owner financial harm. An average home owner should be able to ride out a crash/correction in their own home. We do wish to warn those in denial that there is a downside risk and that they shouldn't put themselves underwater and assume the tide will help them float.

I reserve my Schadenfreude for the speculators, dishonest real estate agents, easy money speculators, corrupt apraisers and mortgage bankers who give away bad loans as though they were Santa Claus. Most of these folks deserve a good spanking.

formerly_anonymous said...

Keith - are you serious? How can you say "is everyone here running a sprint or a race?" when you are advocating to ignore 40 years straight of median home sale gains and instead say "sell all real estate NOW!"

All I was saying is that you made 5 stock picks last month, and all 5 of them turned out bad. The odds of that happening are 1 in 32.....that is real difficult to do.........let me know when you are in Vegas so I can bet the "DON'T COME" when you shoot craps.

Also, I didn't come up with "Renter Panic", but I wish I had.....that is a good one.

Dogcrap Green said...

It's so hard to type when you can stop laughing.

Mortgage rates are falling just when the baby boomers are getting ready to retire.

The economy is coming back.

What next?

The collasp of energy cost?
Under 3% unemployment?
Evidense that Americans are improving their net worth by REDUCING debt?

Just laughing and enjoying the good times. How about you?

Dogcrap Green said...

this blog is the best!!!

Sorry ment can't stop laughing.

Housing Panic. The combination of your simple thinking skills match with your arogence and topped off with the inability to admit being wrong will destroy you.

Thanks for the entertainment!!!

an_dochasach said...

keith b,
Can you explain what COP is? Yahoo stock ticker lists it as Conoco Philips, which hasn't much to do with housing other than that when oil goes up, suburban property loses value.

I noticed SRPIX is down right now, where is this optimism coming from? SS is heading towards bankruptcy, inflation adjusted wages have stagnated or fallen, our trade deficit is worse than ever, oil is double what it was in 2003 and American consumers and car companies are stuck with more oil-hungry SUVs than they know what to do with. Where will the money come from if house prices continue to rise?

My stock picks:
2) The company which provides ink for fed reserve currency printers.
3) The company which produces brown envelopes (for bribes)
4) Kyocera or another Japanese tech company (they've learned from their mistakes, we haven't, deflating the property bubble might partially reinflate the tech bubble.)
5) A put on a crane company
6) Stock in a crane salvage and recycling company.

Anonymous said...

Is anyone planning on getting cheap mortgage money now while waiting for the housing price correction ?

Since there are two views of the future (higher/lower interest rates), it seems that for those that have significant equity in a house now, and are considering buying a second home or investment property after prices correct, it would make sense to get a mortgage now.

If the future holds higher interest rates, you will be in good shape. If the future is lower rates, you can just pay off the mortgage. Since the spread is so low between the rates, you wouldn't won't loose much in the interim (I personally also get a discounted rate since my wife works at the bank which further reduces the spread).

Also, in the worst case hyper-inflation scenario, you would still benefit with the spread working in your favor.

Anyone else thinking the same (or know a good reason not to) ?

keith said...

dogcrap - time will tell my friend. time will tell.

I hope you keep coming here week after week as it happens. You know where I'll be.

Renter_Panic said...


The Thinker said...

Anonymous, if housing starts to fall I would expect interest rates would fall as well. I dont see why you would want to take on extra debt now.

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

Just as soon as I say "I'll never step in dog crap again" I do.

Why is that?

My bet is that it is in governments intrest to keep the baby boomers working.

an_dochasach said...

Since Ireland is 3 just steps behind in its stairway to property heaven, I'm interested in how the collapse plays out in parts of the U.S. where the bubble was strongest.

The statistics which puzzle me the most are the markets (FL,WA,CA,D.C.) where inventory is rising at the same time as median price is rising.

Did the law of supply and demand suddenly evaporate in this "new economy?" But then I thought about what happens when first time buyers finally drop out of a market. Wouldn't that tend to cause a spike in the median sale price? To be sure, the spike is short lived as speculators are feeding off other speculators without any underlying reality to support their stairway to heaven.

Lobbing off the bottom of a bell-curve is almost certain to raise the mean. If this is the case, is there any way of measuring this?

keith said...

from my view in AZ, where inventories have nearly tripled the past 6 months, while prices have yet to plummet, here's my take talking to folks with houses for sale

they didn't get the memo.

basically, they say neighbors who sold their homes for crazy prices (like me). and they still think they can get those prices or more.

but alas, with exploding inventories, no buyers, and investors who have fled, the only way their homes will sell is with drastic price reductions. they're not even getting any lookers.

one neighbor who put her place out at 40% above where even I sold mine for said that she hasn't gotten one looker in 3 months.

but check this out. she plans on RAISING the price this month? Why? Because she thinks since it hasn't sold in 3 months, she has 3 more months of APPRECIATION

that's what's happening here. you'll see inventory build, sales dry up, and THEN you'll see the prices come down.

Anonymous said...

Does anybody know what's up with Glendale, California. We know a flipper there who said it's basically immune to trouble because of a large Armenian population who just keeps buying.

formerly_anonymous said...

There was SO much PANIC when the yield curve inverted last month........I imagine that everyone on this blog is SO relieved now that the yield curve has reverted......

I love the month of January....this is the time when I get to thank my lucky stars for all the mortgage deductions I can take from my taxes. Thank you all you renters for subsidizing my mortgage.


Keith_B -

FNM sure took a hit today on your so called "bogus news"........must have been a bad day for you on your FNM short sale.

FANNIE MAE (NYSE:FNM) Delayed quote data
After Hours (RT-ECN): 54.00 0.20 (0.37%)
Last Trade: 53.80
Trade Time: 4:00PM ET
Change: 0.62 (1.17%)

Anonymous said...

I live in Glendale. The Armenian people are the shrewdest business people in the world. It is part of their culture. I have never won doing business with them.

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

I am delighted to see the confidince in the stock and real estate sectors in light of all the negative fundemental data.
This is what is required to eliminate your savings and drive the prices down. Cash will be king again and baby boomers will work into their 70's taking the burden off social security.
God bless America! Hurray for Kieth! See you some time after 2009. In the mean time , I will continue to work and live debit free without paying your rent. God bless the savers and those living within their means.

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

I remember in the California crash of 1991 when I lived in the desert. There were so many homes on the market you could rent for pennies on the dollar. Is that the case where you are YET???

formerly_anonymous said...

devest -

don't you remember? in an earlier post, Keith said he is paying 2k a month in rent until he moves to the UK.......that is a lot of pennies

panicearly said...

greetings from tokyo,14th year of price declines. US maynot have as long of a stagnating period due to some structural differences but if the japan bubble is any guide hang on to your shirts, and pants too. from the peak prices in 1989-91, the property prices have dropped between 70-almost 90%, that said it is still an expensive city. home loans here are 2%arms, 3-4% fixed. and properties are still not moving. when enough people get burnt, and go negative , they cant buy even at 1% loans. who wants to give you a loan when you havent paid off the last one? perhaps american lenders, they seem to be the only ones with low enough standards for qualifications.

keith said...

formerly - it's called a weekly VACATION rental. They charge hotel like rates here in Arizona. $2g a month is a steal.

A real rental (12 month lease) would be substantially less.

But to get a vacation rental (beautiful place - view of all of phoenix and mountains, pool, jacuzzi, etc) at $2g a month shows you how bad the rental market is here - vacation or regular.

keith said...

panicearly - what would you think about investing in Japan stocks, or even buying Japan real estate? Doesn't seem like your housing can go down anymore, does it? Nice time to enter (somehow - no idea how to do that)

If you bought a condo in Japan today, could you rent it out and get positive cash flow?

That's the kicker here - you'd be happy to get 50% of the cost of ownership in rent.

moonvalley said...

All I can say is we're all lucky Florida Real Estate and Real Estate nationwide cannot be easily traded online through the likes of Scottrade and Ameritrade because if real estate traded ..You would see a major correction in a matter of a week. All those condo flippers would be Flipping off there shiny new balconies.
Ah, you speak to soon..as to selling condos online..don't forget ebay

Condos galore...the best buys seem to be the KittyyCondos at least they come with Catnip!

moonvalley said...

...and even more real estate and condos online.

Anonymous said...

I keep hearing the negatives. The 4 areas i'm familiar with our still trending up. I don't need stats or realtor to tell me bubble or no bubble.

austin- up

socal-los angeles,oc,san fernando valley, ventura, santa clarita etc- all up

hawaii maui- up

salt lake city - up

All of these areas still are moving
up and plenty of buyers. no gloom and doom. alot of the socal areas have buyers with multiple families purchasing together and living together i've seen more and more of this the last 4 years.

2 or 3 years before we see any real drop in prices. The interest only holders will hold on for a while. Most of these loans we locked for 5 years starting back in 02,03,04, which means 07,08,09 due. I keep hearing rates are up, what rate, rates 30year and adjustables are real close to there lows but i keep hearing rates are up. Lastly i think the only issue is will foreigners keep buying our debt, thats the real question.

panicearly said...

There are some deals in tokyo, i just bought here recently. rents are stable, price to rent is at 5%,not good not bad, but i did see some places that can easily get 10%-12%. the problem here is financing for foreigners, though i here there is a small foreign bank thats focused on relaestate and it deals with non japanese. There is quite a bit of activity in foreclosures and renovations. i bought my place through a renovation company, so there was no realtor in between. It could go down some more i think in order for it to be an good investment.

keith said...

panic early

when japan home values were at the top - say $1 million US for a 2-bed condo, what would it cost a month to own a place, and what would it cost per month to rent the same place? How out of whack did it get?

And were they using "creative" mortgages - interest only, zero down,etc? What's a normal mortgage over there now - 30 years?


trollbrothers said...

Everything is fine. Don't miss the boat! Come buy a home before all the land is gone! Listen to the President. The only problem is that the naysayers are trying to bring us down.

panicearly said...

to keith b, there was complete disconnect with rate of returns, the players just did not care even if the rents can pay for interest payments, they got rewarded with higher appraisals the minute they closed a purchase. a 2ldk in tokyo, say 700sq
which is 2 bedrms, 1 living, 1 dining
could not be had for 1 millionus$ more
closer to 2mil if the building was reasonable would rent for $2300. if the location was really great than 5000$. the rents are still the same today but the values in ok areas are 400,000 and 700,000 respectivley. Im living in an older building but 10 min. walk from a great shopping area(shibuya) and paid about 540,000 for a 1600sq, 4 bedroom. an amazing deal as i can easily rent this out to even english teachers at 1000$ per room and at 5000$ for the whole place.

keith said...

panicearly - same thing going on here in the US now. Rents flat - for years. While home prices doubled past 4 years in many areas.

And rent income would only cover 50% or so of cost of housing.

Thus, pretty obvious what's coming

Anonymous said...

I live in Glendale. The Armenian people are the shrewdest business people in the world. It is part of their culture. I have never won doing business with them.

So, does this mean there's merit in our flipper friend's claim that Glendale is immune to a bursting bubble?

panicearly said...

keith b. yep i think its coming, or actually here. by the time you read it in major publications its in swing. even a 10% correction for people who bought in 2004 or 2005 will tie their their hands. a 20 would sink them, especially if you consider, closing costs, commisions, and moving into a new place etc. at 10% loss on a 400,000 home, you have to cough up 40,000 in cash plus misc fees just to get out. 50 grand to just walk away clear even if you got a better job offer elsewhere its hard to accept it, and thats the bright side.

Anonymous said...

I have been buying and selling Homes and condos ( I have never played in the condo pre sale game)for nearly 20 years... the last three I have only been selling.(Im glad I kept a few as rentals) I would buy the Homes do a complete restoration ie kitchens baths flooring landscaping roofing. I would carry the properties for almost six months during the entire process..I would then sell and make between 12-20 thousand a deal after all that hard work. I enjoyed making a difference in the neighborhood by taking the ugly duckling house and making it the swan. The last few years I started noticing that many speculators would buy a house not even mow the lawn and make 50 grand. WOW just like magic. Condos in my building would sell three times without a single person moving in. I tell You its pure BS there is no justification for these prices. IN This part of Broward County Florida I have seen a 42,000 condo in 2000 sell for 170,000 today. Its still in a bad neighborhood. Lately inventories are rising at such a dramatic pace that I truly believe South Florida is heading towards a 10-12 mo supply of Homes not to mention dot.condos . On another note I have friends who work for large builders and they made a killing in Places like Florida and Las Vegas as the cookie cutter House stayed the same but the prices tripled. 100 percent mark up. Greed ...

Anonymous said...

Does anybody know when real estate busted in the early 90's what did that do to rents? up or down.

ShameonLyingAgents said...

Check out El Paso - another case of lower priced markets increasing in value as equilibrium is reached.

IMHO the big story of the next 5-10 years will be an explosion in population and prices in such markets as the air slowly seeps out of some of the more inflated markets and inflates other places.

Real estate values to go up

Vic Kolenc
El Paso Times
Sunday, January 8, 2006

El Paso home prices continue to rise. Data from the Real Estate Center at Texas A&M University show El Paso's median home price increased 16 percent during 11 months of last year, the latest data available, to $109,100 -- the third-highest increase among 32 Texas metro areas tracked.

In November, the median price increased 25 percent compared with the same month in 2004, to $120,000, the highest percentage increase among 27 metro areas.

The National Association of Realtors and the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight's price index also show El Paso with strong home price gains during the first nine months of 2005.

And a recent ranking done for Fortune magazine projected that El Paso's home prices in 2006 would rise 8.1 percent -- the third-best forecast rate in the nation, just behind San Antonio and Jacksonville, Fla.

"It's a crazy market, unbelievable," said Lupe Mata, broker-owner of Premier Real Estate.


An influx of out-of-town investors and a tight inventory of houses are causing prices to rise, said Mata and others in the real estate industry.

"Fifty percent of my business is now with out-of-town investors," Mata said. "They are the ones lifting our prices."

Rob Hovious, who this month retired as vice president of Coldwell Banker De Wetter Hovious, one of the city's largest real estate companies, said he's never seen the El Paso market this hot with this kind of investor interest during his 41 years in the El Paso real estate business. National stories about Fort Bliss expansion have caught investors' attention, while housing supply has not kept up with the stronger demand, he said.

Lorenzo Mata, 48, an El Paso high-school principal, decided to take advantage of the hot market to sell the West Side home he and his wife, Rebecca, have owned for about 20 years.

It took less than a month for the Matas to get a sales contract on their four-bedroom house for just under its $190,000 listed sales price. The contract is pending.

But the couple are also seeing the other end of the market. They have a contract to purchase a new, slightly smaller home, also on the West Side, for more than $200,000.

"I feel pretty good about buying and selling," Lorenzo Mata said. "Selling helps me buy the new house, and interest rates are good for buying. The way the market is going, I don't think I can lose."

Number hash

National Association of Realtors' data have El Paso's median home price growing at 19.5 percent in the first nine months of 2005 when compared with the same time in 2004 -- better than the national average of 14.7 percent. Meanwhile, the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight's broad House Price Index showed El Paso prices increasing 8.35 percent for the first nine months of 2005 -- below the national average of 12.2 percent.

"Don't get hung up on the numbers. Whether it's 8, 16 or 19 percent. ... El Paso is doing quite well in home-price appreciation," said Jim Gaines, research economist at the Real Estate Center at Texas A&M University. The numbers vary because each organization uses different data and different ways of measuring the data, Gaines said.

Even with the recent price gains, El Paso continues to be a "pretty affordable market," Gaines said. The Real Estate Center's latest price affordability index shows a "family earning El Paso's median income ($38,250) has 151 percent of required income to qualify to buy a median-priced house, assuming 20 percent down and a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage," he said.

Mark Dotzour, chief economist at the Real Estate Center, said other large Texas metro markets, such as Dallas and Houston, saw less price appreciation in 2005 than El Paso, partly because those markets are known for easily increasing housing construction when demand rises. El Paso has less easily developable land, he said.

Pricier homes built

El Paso's increased median home price also is partly the result of more expensive homes being on the market, Dotzour said.

In 2000, 31.3 percent of El Paso homes sold were at the $100,000-plus level, Real Estate Center data show. In 2005, an estimated 56.1 percent of El Paso homes sold were at that price level.

How long El Paso's surging home prices will continue is the big question, Gaines said. Large increases will be difficult to sustain if investors' speculation is causing most of the price appreciation, he said. "If it's not due to a lot of (price) speculation, then it may sustain itself. But it probably won't continue for the next five years."

Fortune magazine's price forecast for 2006, which was compiled by Fiserv CSW, a home price research company, and Moody's Economy.com, an economic research provider, has some hot real estate markets losing steam. Las Vegas, which had price gains of 44 percent in 2004, according to Fortune, is ranked last in the price forecast with a projected 7.9 percent price decline in 2006.


The Thinker said...

And still, a strong case has not been made on this board for the view that a drop in real estate values is imminent.

Yes homes are over valued. They were over valued for a long time and still no crash.

I know a few people who sold their house 3 years ago to move into a smaller house/rent and are kicking themselves today.

Luke said...

So, do you think they will double in price again this year?

Anonymous said...

Anybody have info on the seattle housing market. Thanks

the thinker said...

No, I dont think housing prices will double this year, but they may continue to go up...

dcdawg1234 said...

There are some intersting new realestate mashups at: http://googlemapsmania.blogspot.com/2006/01/7-new-google-maps-us-real-estate.html
for dc/CA/sf/seattle.

dcdawg1234 said...

There are some intersting new realestate mashups at: http://googlemapsmania.blogspot.com/2006/01/7-new-google-maps-us-real-estate.html
for dc/CA/sf/seattle.

dcdawg1234 said...

There are some intersting new realestate mashups at: http://googlemapsmania.blogspot.com/2006/01/7-new-google-maps-us-real-estate.html
for dc/CA/sf/seattle.

Anonymous said...

Home P/E ratios for 9 metro areas
Avg. 1988-2000 2001
Boston 20.5 30.2
San Diego 22.8 29.7
San Francisco 23.8 27.2
Los Angeles 21.3 25.6
Seattle 20.4 25

Seattle is not looking good.......

Anonymous said...

In the first quarter of 2001 the average price of a single-family home there rose 4%, but by the end of the year had fallen 7%. "We're seeing a bubble bursting right now in San Francisco," says Robert Shiller, an economics professor at Yale University and partner at Case Weiss Shiller. "We've never seen such a sharp drop, and we're expecting it to fall even more." Shiller, who warned of a stock market bubble in the late 1990s and coined the phrase "irrational exuberance," believes there's the risk of a housing bubble in other major cities. At the top of his watch list are Portland, Ore., Seattle, Denver, and New York.

Anonymous said...

If you want to see for yourself just how far out of whack the Seattle market is check out this listing:

MLS 26000601. And it gets better-that place is practically UNDER I-5.

Seattle is a joke- choked w/ traffic and no signs of ever having one in the future- they just put the kabosh on a rapid transit system.

The only thing nice here is the weather and the only reason I think that is because I'm from Maine and spent last year in Upstate NY.

000000000000000000000000000000000000 said...

Anonymous said...
Does anybody know when real estate busted in the early 90's what did that do to rents? up or down.

Rents unchanged.
Money short.
Asset liquidation followed by consumer inactivity.

Remember trickle down?
short sale, cash is king?

Anonymous said...

I'm starting to worry about what to do w/ my downpayment $ that I'm planning to put to good use once housing crashes.

I did really well with regular CD's in the 80's (interest at 18%-duh) and , being a (scared and) very conservative investor, am very tempted to take everything out of the stock market and just put it in my credit union.

What are people's thoughts on this kind of move?

I'm not too worried about interest rates going back down to previous low levels, but I am a little worried lately about dollars suddenly losing all value- am I being a complete alarmist about that?

Anonymous said...

Any info on Portland, Oregon's housing market would be greatly appreciated. Are we in a bubble? If so by how much?
I can't find hardly any news that Portland is out of whack.

Nathan said...

To answer your question regarding rents, from the sample I looked at, there was not a decline in nominal rents in most markets, but the rate of increase was fairly flat.

Anonymous said...

Keith; great blog but why does it display the most recent postings at the bottom of the page? I look on it on different computers/browsers with the same results

inseattle said...

Re. the Portland market: it seems to be very similar to the Seattle one,eg. over-priced and stalled, with the general consensus being "our area is different, no bad bubble here".

Typical head in the sand approach to life.

If you want to see what's REALLY going on,

1) choose a neighborhood in Portland and go to the MLS list. Plunck in your criteria (ie. price, square ft., etc) and see what comes up.

Then go back every few days and see how different the list looks for same neighborhood and same criteria.

My list for Seattle has showed a striking change in the past couple days (ie. more pages of houses = more houses on the market).

2) Then go to Craigslist and search portland RE for "reduced" every few days. The numbers of "reduced" should be growing exponentially soon, if it hasn't already started in Ptld.

While you're on Craigslist, every now and again when you have a moment, click on one of the properties.

I found a doozy the other day. They were trying to bribe people into coming to the open house by giving away free Starbucks giftcards to the 1st 20 people and also having a drawing for a $100 Nordstroms gift card.

Now, I don't know about Ptld. but I do know that in Seattle this sort of desperation to sell a house has not been present for a good many years.

Sound like the market might just possibly be tanking? Pretty soon it'll be hard for people to spin this in a positive direction, no matter how hard they try. For the time being tho, they are still trying.

keith said...

Portland info from http://www.benengebreth.org/housingtracker/

Holding up pretty well, except for high-end

Trend 01/07/2006 1 month 2 month 3 month 4 month
Median Price $325,000 0.0% -0.3% 0.0% -1.5%
Inventory 4,121 -6.9% -14.1% -13.4% -6.2%

Historical Data
Date Inventory 25th Percentile 50th Percentile
(Median) 75th Percentile
01/07/2006 4,121 $239,900 $325,000 $499,000
01/01/2006 3,986 $239,500 $325,000 $499,000
12/28/2005 4,157 $239,000 $324,900 $499,000
12/21/2005 4,263 $239,000 $325,000 $497,000
12/14/2005 4,364 $236,500 $325,000 $495,000
12/07/2005 4,426 $235,000 $325,000 $499,000
12/01/2005 4,440 $235,895 $329,900 $499,900
11/28/2005 4,488 $236,950 $329,900 $499,900
11/21/2005 4,674 $239,000 $329,000 $499,000
11/14/2005 4,710 $236,097 $329,000 $499,000
11/07/2005 4,800 $234,900 $325,900 $499,000
11/01/2005 4,836 $239,000 $329,900 $499,900
10/28/2005 4,848 $238,500 $329,900 $499,900
10/21/2005 4,865 $234,900 $329,900 $499,999
10/14/2005 4,848 $235,000 $327,750 $499,900
10/07/2005 4,759 $234,900 $325,000 $499,500
10/01/2005 4,769 $234,950 $327,000 $499,900
09/28/2005 4,800 $234,900 $329,000 $499,900
09/21/2005 4,750 $234,900 $329,500 $499,950
09/14/2005 4,588 $231,000 $329,000 $509,900
09/07/2005 4,395 $229,950 $329,900 $509,900
09/01/2005 4,377 $229,900 $330,000 $519,000
08/28/2005 4,373 $229,900 $329,900 $511,300
08/21/2005 4,337 $228,000 $329,000 $509,900
08/14/2005 4,241 $229,000 $329,900 $520,000

keith said...

on comments - it is what it is with blogger - sorry!

chris said...

Keith; Thanks for the info on Portland, OR.
here's my dilema. I like many sold a house in San Diego over the summer that tripled in value since I bought it in 1999 before the big run up in prices. I preserved my equity so after cashing out I walked away with a cool 290,000. I moved hee to Portland and bought a 2100 sq ft 4 bed , 2 bath, garage and basement on a nice sized lot remodeled bungalo in the inner SE in the older neighborhoods for 222K I put down 120K so my mortgage on it is only 500.00/mo. Then I purchased a duplex in the same nieghborhood for 239,000 I put down 25,000 on it. The duplex built in 1996 1800 sq ft in perfect condition. I rent on of the 900 sq ft units for 750.00/mo and the other one for 725.00/mo currently I have one vacant and I had a bad tennant I had to evict so I'm seeking another tennant now. Being a landlord does suck but I've been told by 2 realtors in November that I could sell it at 265-279K they said that maybe more if I wait till the spring. I want to get out and make a profit on it. I think I'd like to pay a MLS listing fee of $400 to $500.00 to avoid RE commisions. I don't see very many duplexes for sale in Portland and I figure once I get another tennant so it's fully occupied then it might be easier to sell. ANY ADVICE ON WHAT I SHOULD DO OR SHOULD I HOLD OUT UNTIL SPRING/SUMMER TO SELL OR DUMP IT NOW??
I hear that more California investors are still moving here.

Anonymous said...

Keep reading for stock picks.

I use ebay and it sucks. In the early years it was like the gold rush. I would get over retail for stuff. Today stuff sells for "sight unseen wholesale" with the posibility of fraud. Supply has exceded demand. Sure it can go up. Is it worth it, HECK NO! Can someone else start up somthing competitive? Heck Yes! Ebay's formula for success = Give the service away, slowly charging, then raising fees to their current gouging levels after going public.

Anonymous said...

I'm getting the impression that most posters/readers on this and other housing bubble blogs are waiting for the crash so they can finally buy a home, esp. in overheated markets. But what if the US market repeats the pattern in 1990's Japan, where the monster bubble of the late 80's deflated slowly over a period of almost 15 years? If we have a similar pattern, which I believe is likely, you could buy in 2008, when house values are off 25-30 from the peak, and by 2011 your mortgage will be worth more than your house, which will be off 50% from the peak.

Grinch34 said...

I'm getting the impression that most posters/readers on this and other housing bubble blogs are waiting for the crash so they can finally buy a home, esp. in overheated markets. But what if the US market repeats the pattern in 1990's Japan, where the monster bubble of the late 80's deflated slowly over a period of almost 15 years? If we have a similar pattern, which I believe is likely, you could buy in 2008, when house values are off 25-30 from the peak, and by 2011 your mortgage will be worth more than your house, which will be off 50% from the peak.

Wednesday, January 11, 2006 1:17:03 PM

You may be right on some accounts, except the situation is unprecedented for the following reasons:
1.Massive debt for country.
2.Massive loss of good paying jobs with benefits.
3. Massive loss of retirements.
4. Massive amounts of jobs directly (also indirectly) tied into the buying and selling of homes.
5. Massive amounts of so-called exotic loans, which are loaned to people who will be unable to pay them back.
6.Unlike the 80's, Interest rates will either stay about the same or will go up, so refinacing will not be an option to lower payments.

With all that said, I hope you are right because the consequences of a sudden crash are going to be dire for everybody.

Anonymous said...

I AM waiting for the housing market to crash. I want prices to go so low that I can basically buy the house outright.

After that , I'll just live a nice quiet life.

Anonymous said...

Prev. ANON
It wont crash and hit rock bottom. Come down some and level off. But not down to 200-2001 prices. So...if you cant get in today, I doubt you will tommorrow. Especially with rates rising.

foxwoodlief said...

Again all the "chicken little's" out there are being sooooo apocolyptic. Yes, even I wish I could have bought a house in San Jose for $16000 in 1963 like my parent's did, have a great job, live off one income, and have multiple pensions when I retire, but it ain't going to happen!

In 1980 friends of mine bought a house in Phoenix for a whopping $85,000 at 14% interest for 1600 sq ft. Now that translates into $215,000 in today's dollars and if you had that mortgage at 14% today, well, don't cry for me Argentina at 8% or less.

People still refuse to take all the factors for the price of a home in to account, location, job market, interest rates, size of home, ammenities, adjusted for inflation, current building costs, etc. If the stock market stayed flat for a year (gosh, it did in 2005) would people feel the market had no where to go or that some stocks were unde-rvalued and other's over-valued? At some point prices have to stop rising as demand slackens, interest rates rise, job growth slows but that doesn't mean the end of the world and the next GREAT DEPRESSION. Though even in the depression with 30% unemployement (and no social safety net) that meant 70% worked.

And even in 2006 the entire capitalization of the nations real estate, adjusted for inflation, still does match Japan's in the 80s, a country the size of California and one that isn't growing and has 300 million people. Nor is every homeowner tapped out in his equity (even with a 50% drop in some markets) or can't make his mortgage payments.

If the market slows there will be bargains in many areas, especially if the local economy doesn't support incomes or job growth and people paid too much. Here in Phoenix we bought a house in the historic district in 1994 for $62 a sq ft and it needed work. We sold it four years later for $130 a sq ft but not until we sunk $40 a sq ft into a total remodel. Today in that same neighborhood people are asking $200 a sq ft for a dump. Plan and simple math: overpriced. Now if those folks had put $$ into updating those houses they might not be so overvalued but as with most greedy people (not just investors) there are people who don't maintain their homes, invest in their neighborhoods and because some guy down the street did and sells, jackpot, they think they DESERVE the same price for their piece of crap without investing to make it more valuable. Then the guy who buys can't afford to update and remodel without being way over-invested and the neighborhood still looks like hell with $200,000 home as it did at $60,000 homes. Part of the problem in California...too much speculative money and not enough reinvestment in those homes.

I think most of the guys who "gleefully" anticipate a meltdown are just plain envious of those who made wise investments or went to college so they earn enough to live in nice homes or are like those idiots in the neighborhoods I've invested in who want a jackpot without the sweat equity or labor.

Be careful what you wish for as my mom use to say, it might happen. Meltdown? When I spent some time in Ecuador a few years back after their economy melted down it didn't matter that you could buy an apartment in the equivelent neighborhood in Quito as Fifth Avenue for as little as $25,000, if you didn't have a job, you had no money. If you had a job and no money you couldn't get credit to buy. If you had the cash you didn't invest it in Ecuador. Is that what you idiots want with the US? So greedy and selfish that all you want is the prices to fall so you can "pay cash" and to hell with the world?

Oh and you think your cash would be safe in a meltdown? Remember the bank runs in the 30s? Remember cash is fiat money and unless you have it stuffed in your mattress it ain't really there.

Oh, and for several of you bloggers who have implied that I'm a realtor, not. I'm a Director of Radiology in a Phoenix Hospital and my wife works at a Law firm and you know there really is a LOT OF REAL money here in Phoenix.

Anonymous said...

Cool blog thanks for posting this information. http://www.racingnewsdaily.com

Car Loans home said...

Hi Thanks for your interesting blog. I also have a blog/site, covering best car loans
related stuff. Feel free to visit my best car loans

James Baker said...

I was just searching blogs,and I found your site, Friend! I like it!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success.
If you have a moment, please take a look at my site:
pennsylvania home equity loan rate
It pretty much covers pennsylvania home equity loan rate related issues.
All the best!

carpet cleaners plano texas said...

Hey Great Blog! Need any information on cleaning Check out my web site carpet cleaners plano texas it relates to carpet cleaners plano texas

Anonymous said...

I was looking for blogs referring to Dallas and found yours. Great blog! I'm in Dallas and here's some info about me

real estate listings said...

You have a great website here, and I'm going to tell all my friends about it.

answer-man said...

Hello just stopped by to view your blog and to let all interested know I am offering free plumbing repair information and safety tips for California residents and all others interested. If you are not interested then please excuse us and please disregard this comment.

For Plumbing Press Release and Free Plumbing Repair Information please feel free and stop by and read and take advantage of our blog info or viist **A-Affordableplumbing.Com** Thank you and have a great day.

Online Degree Adviser said...

Hello, Just wandering the blogosphere and happened on your blog. I like the way how you have put it all together. I'll be coming back again.


condo for rent

Tim said...

Hey!! Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching 2 card company credit new online york. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though your blog is way off base from 2 card company credit new online york I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don�t your url and feel free to visit me here at http://www.credit-cardcompany.com/. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

Paul Adams said...

Hi, Fellow!I like your blog!
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
I have a loans center
site. It pretty much covers loans center related subjects.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Best regards!

Paul Adams said...

Congratulations Friend for your excellent blog on loans center!Keep up the good work!
If you have a moment, please visit my site:
loans center
I send you my warm regards and wish you continued success.
Have a nice day! :-)

Anonymous said...

Enjoyed reading some of your blog. Nice to take a break from my own real estate work. Selling homes is getting to be a challenging business right now. Good luck, and thanks for the read. Visit my site if you have a chance.

Anonymous said...

I can never spend enough time blogging because I�m busy with my own real estate work, but I enjoyed your site. Too brief a visit, but thanks for the insight. Visit my site if you have a chance.

total debt elimination said...

Hi Fellow! I was just searching blogs,and I found yours! I like it!
If you have a moment, please visit my total debt elimination site.
Good luck!

Anonymous said...

I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both
reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com


amortization of loan costs said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my amortization of loan costs site.
Have a great week!

amortization rates said...

Hello Friend! I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here!
If you have a moment, please make a visit to my amortization rates site.
Good luck in your endeavors!

arizona aerospace engineer job sites said...

Your blog I found to be very interesting!
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
I have a arizona aerospace engineer job sites
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Best regards!

Scott Arthur Edwards said...

The fact is that the INTERNET is making people WEALTHY! Shouldn't YOU be one of them? Dear friend, I don't know about you, but I like to be free from a job and able to travel anywhere around the globe. Here is the key to doing just that...Click here on my rotation link and join me so you can be free as a bird and clear of financial worries: FIND OUT NOW!

arkansas home loans said...

Hi Fellow! I was just searching blogs,and I found yours! I like it!
If you have a moment, please visit my arkansas home loans site.
Good luck!

arizona refinance mortgage rate said...

I was searching blogs,and I found yours.Please,
accept my congratulations for your excellent work!
If you have a moment, please visit my arizona refinance mortgage rate site.
Have a good day!

arm calculator interest mortgage only said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my arm calculator interest mortgage only site.
Have a great week!

arm calculator interest mortgage only said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my arm calculator interest mortgage only site.
Have a great week!

arm calculator interest mortgage only said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my arm calculator interest mortgage only site.
Have a great week!

arm calculator interest mortgage only said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my arm calculator interest mortgage only site.
Have a great week!

australian job search said...

This is an excellent blog. Keep it going.You are providing
a great resource on the Internet here!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my australian job search site.
Have a great week!

value of pokemon cards said...

This is an excellent blog. Keep it going.You are providing
a great resource on the Internet here!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my value of pokemon cards site.
Have a great week!

stock market research said...

Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my stock market research site.
Have a great week!

auto bad credit loan private said...

Hi Friend! You have a great blog over here!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my auto bad credit loan private site.
Have a great day!

automobile insurance state comparison said...

This is an excellent blog. Keep it going.You are providing
a great resource on the Internet here!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my automobile insurance state comparison site.
Have a great week!

stock market prices said...

I was searching blogs,and I found yours.Please,
accept my congratulations for your excellent work!
If you have a moment, please visit my stock market prices site.
Have a good day!

automobile liability insurance said...

A fantastic blog yours. Keep it up.
If you have a moment, please visit my automobile liability insurance site.
I send you warm regards and wish you continued success.

auto loan amortization chart said...

I was searching blogs,and I found yours.Please,
accept my congratulations for your excellent work!
If you have a moment, please visit my auto loan amortization chart site.
Have a good day!

auto loan payment said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a auto loan payment site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)

Debt Consolidation Refinance said...

Your Blog. It's nice. Here's a subject that may interest you; California mortgage refinancing Bad Credit? check out http:\\thedebtconsolidationfaq.com. Thanks again for the blog!

bargainannual travel insurance said...

Hi Fellow! I was just searching blogs,and I found yours! I like it!
If you have a moment, please visit my bargainannual travel insurance site.
Good luck!

wisconsin flea market said...

Hey Fellow, you have a top-notch blog here!
If you have a moment, please have a look at my wisconsin flea market site.
Good luck!

building contents home insurance said...

Hello Friend! I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here!
If you have a moment, please make a visit to my building contents home insurance site.
Good luck in your endeavors!

boots travel insurance said...

Hi Friend! You have a great blog over here!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my boots travel insurance site.
Have a great day!

brick nj automobile insurance business said...

Hi Fellow! I was just searching blogs,and I found yours! I like it!
If you have a moment, please visit my brick nj automobile insurance business site.
Good luck!

Jane Carpenter said...

A fantastic blog yours. Keep it up.
If you have a moment, please visit my retail banking site.
I send you warm regards and wish you continued success.

Meg Taylor said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a rfq lease leaseback california 2006 site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)

Libra Litrou said...

Cool blog.


Libra Litrou

Anonymous said...

your sitecold spring granite was interesting. here is myhttp://www.usend1.net.or go to it from here cold spring granite