June 03, 2006

The too much liquidity (credit bubble) pitfall - lessons from past financial crises


So when the NASDAQ blew up in 2000 - 2001, combined with 9/11, we saw the Fed step on the gas, flooding the world with excess capital in order to restimulate the economy. Not a bad idea. The bad idea was keeping the foot to the pedal too long. And now we'll pay the price. Big time.

Excess leads to pullback. And the mother of all credit bubbles, where so many individual investors are not only involved in the asset bubble, but also leveraged to the hilt, well, the world has never seen anything like this credit orgy.

And the world will never see what they're about to see again. Thank god.

THE spectacular Wall Street crash of Black Monday, October 19, 1987, saw equity prices record their biggest one-day fall since the Great Depression. The experience was a memorable, if unhappy, one for investors at the time.

But looking back there is something else about the crash that is both interesting and important. It might have been the world's first modern financial crisis.

The Fed has responded to these modern financial crises by quickly pumping out liquidity, by reassuring market players of its readiness to intervene to prevent market failure and by knocking heads together where necessary.

The Fed's aim was to stop a fire sale of assets, and credit problems cascading through the financial system, leading to the failure of financial institutions, systemic problems and economic recession. Nobody could sensibly object to that.

The problem, which Kohn only obliquely acknowledges, is that the Fed left too much money in the system for too long and kept interest rates too low.

Financial markets recovered quickly, but too much liquidity led to price and other pressures, rising interest rates and asset price falls and recession. This is a lesson that needs to be absorbed.

Investors and the financial institutions which manage their money and their risk need to remember that while central banks will act to stop a financial crisis leading to systemic damage, it isn't their business to protect individual investors or financial institutions from serious losses.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

http://tinyurl.com/mfb8m

Japan Policy Reasearch Institute Working Paper No. 109 (April 2006)

This recent paper by Marshall Auerback is an excellent summary of the mortgage bubble created in Japan (maintained by China via GSEs such as FNM in the leveraged MBS market) now in the process of unwinding as the yen/USD carry-trade deflates.

The books "Millionaire", "Fiat Money Inflation in France" and "The Fabulous History of the Dismal Swamp Company : A Story of George Washington's Times" show that "while history does not aim to prove that 'nothing' is new, it should indicate that not everything is as new as contemporary opinion believes" (Pierre Vilar, "A History of Gold and Money").

Although the quote attributed to VP Cheney is "debt doesn't matter", the full text is "Reagan proved that debt doesn't matter", current arguments regarding impending dollar doom because of unprecedented federal budget deficits having been made in the 1980's, with the Aden Sisters calling for gold upwards of $2000.

This time it is different, or at least different enough.

Anonymous said...

(1) I think Cheney said "Reagan proved that deficits don't matter" to Bush's first Treasury Secretary, after said Secretary questioned the wisdom of even more tax cuts oriented almost exclusively at the super-rich.

Darth's idea of "proof" had NOTHING to do with economic soundness or future rationality, but only that Republicans won't get punished electorally, which is true because the costs of the debt come in far later after these people have already benefitted from the system and are out of there.

"We won the midterm elections, this is our due." is the next justification given to the astonished Secretary for having the tax cuts for the super rich. ("our == us CEO multimillionaires") No economic theory of general welfare. It was only about raw power.

This guy previously had worked in the freaking *Nixon* Administration, which by comparison was like a UC Berkeley faculty lunch.

(2) I agree that the liquidity bubble was made even more by the Bank of Japan than the Fed. Why?

Well they had the mother of all Real Estate Bubbles. On the other hand they had a highly productive export-oriented work force, strong work ethic and an insane savings rate. We're way more screwed.

Anonymous said...

Thank you, "deficits" not "debt".

BOJ has injected one trillion USD to support the dollar, by buying the long end of US debt instruments.

This cannot be reversed without another Paul Volcker at the helm, driving rates up "to suck dollars off the moon".

Anonymous said...

Sorry but the opposite is happening in the real world. Banks are swimming in funds and they are making crazy deals. Here's an example from TX:

Sad-sack builder is Chapter 13, had his 40-ft boat repo-ed lasth month, and is 3 months behind ($2100) on his truck payments. Repo man was due to haul it away on the 5th. He went to the bank on Friday and they paid his note, gave him a loan on a new truck at 8%, and a $2K personal loan to catch up on back payments for a grader!

It looks to me like lending standards have been relaxed a bit...

Anonymous said...

Regarding TX loan portfolios:

Where I am, banks were turned into ice cream parlors, dance studios and drive-through donut shops during the last downdraft in the late 80's.

Anonymous said...

Bottom line is there will be no tightening and true fiscal pain as this mess unfolds. The monetary floodgates are open and the bailouts will happen.

Of course somebody will eventually get stuck with the bill. If you have a retirement account, cash in the bank, or other significant assets, bend over 'cause here comes the golden shaft minus the Vaseline!

Anonymous said...

Yes, BB can sacrifice the dollar and oil&gold shoot past Voyager and through the heliopause, or tighten and collapse the asset bubbles and interest rate derivatives.

Courtesy Columbia Business School ("CBS is great...")
http://tinyurl.com/muakx

Anonymous said...

Very pretty site! Keep working. thnx!
»

Anonymous said...

Allways issues with credit. People just keep using and abusing it. Interesting post and comments. I have a free credit repair site if it will help anyone.